Response to Research Commentary |
From the Departments of Pediatrics (M.S.S., R.C.B.), Cell Biology (M.S.S.), and Biomedical Engineering (R.C.B.), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC.
Correspondence to Madison S. Spach, Box 3475, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710. E-mail cspach{at}acpub.duke.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
max and on the shape of
the foot of the transmembrane action potential (Vm foot).
Resistive discontinuities primarily affect
max, and
an additional capacitive component in the local circuit due to the
capillaries in interstitial space primarily affects
Vm foot. Resistive discontinuities also have an important
influence on cardiac conduction. These discontinuities include spatial
variations in the size of interstitial space
(interstitial resistive discontinuities) and the role of
cellular scaling (effects of cell size) when changes occur in the
cellular and multicellular distribution of gap junctions during
remodeling of normal mature myocardium to proarrhythmic
structural substrates. The full text of this article is available at
http://www.circresaha.org.
Key Words: discontinuous conduction anisotropy action potential foot capillaries interstitial discontinuities
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
max cannot be taken as
definitive evidence of discontinuous propagation or capillary effects.
Specifically, he concludes4 11 that the directional
differences in
max and Vm foot that we
reported12 13 result from the way the tissue was perfused
and the interaction of current flow in the tissue with that in the
surrounding fluid.
For purposes of clarity, we limit our response to uniform
anisotropic myocardium and begin by noting the following
about our recent (1998) article.13 We considered our
experimental tests (and "2-domain" model results) in this paper to
provide strong support for the following hypothesis:
interstitial electrical field interactions between the
electrically passive capillaries and active myocytes produce an
additional interstitial component in the local electrical
circuit of propagating excitation waves in working
myocardium. This extra capacitive component depends on the
direction of propagation in relation to the anisotropic distribution of
the capillaries, and it also depends on the density of the capillaries
and the size of interstitial space. The extra capacitive
component due to normal capillaries primarily affects Vm
foot, with much less effect on
max. This mechanism
represents an extension of the general model of 1-dimensional
cardiac fiber interactions of Medvinskii and Pertsov.14 To
formalize our new "capillary" hypothesis, we developed a 2-domain
model of cardiac muscle represented as 2 separate but
interconnected spaces, anisotropic intracellular space with or without
2-dimensional discrete ventricular cells15 and
anisotropic interstitial space containing the anisotropic
distribution of capillaries. The electrical model was based on the
morphology of working myocardium. When the documented
variations in microstructure (cell geometry, density of capillaries,
and dimensions of interstitial space) were approximated in
the model, its predictions for Vm foot and
max were in good agreement with the experimental
data.13
During longitudinal (LP) and transverse propagation (TP), there was
considerable variability in the general pattern of
max and in the phase-plane trajectories of
Vm foot; eg, there were variable deviations from an
exponential rise of Vm foot. Our hypothesis and model did
not include the perfusing bath effects that have been demonstrated in
the bidomain model studies of Roth and others,1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
because it focused on the tissue at a microscopic size scale. As
detailed in an excellent review by Henriquez,10 bidomain
models of bath effects have considered propagation at the larger
macroscopic level where the stochastic effects of normal cardiac
microstructure are averaged.15 We think these differences
in size scale are highly important when considering our
results12 13 in relation to the effects of the perfusing
bath shown by bidomain models.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
We wish to address the following 3 specific points in response to Roths commentary: (1) matters on which we agree with Roth; (2) ways in which our results are not accounted for by bidomain model results of the bath effect; (3) our conclusion, which we consider to emphasize the need to develop more comprehensive models with the salient characteristic of incorporating features of actual cardiac architecture at the microscopic level.13 15 16
| Points of Agreement Between Experimental Data and Results of Perfusate Effect |
|---|
|
|
|---|
max that we
presented in our 1981 initial report of discontinuous
conduction.12 That is, the rise of the action potential
foot is slower (greater
foot) and
max
is less during fast LP (low-resistance direction) than slow TP
(high-resistance direction). If these general features,
consistent with those of Plonsey and Barr,1 2 were
the only consideration, we would agree that one cannot distinguish
between a mechanism due to the discrete structure of cardiac
muscle12 13 and the effects of the perfusing bath
described in bidomain model studies.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 In retrospect, we also agree with Roth that comparison of the shape of Vm foot in mature myocardium with action potentials measured in single layers of cultured neonatal cells17 (no capillaries) does not distinguish between a capillary mechanism and the superfusate effect. On the other hand, our analysis of the optical action potentials of Fast and Kléber17 provided a necessary first step before proceeding to the major experimental test of the capillary hypothesis, ie, comparison of the phase-plane trajectory of Vm foot in neonatal versus mature ventricular muscle.13 At that time there were no available data about the shape of Vm foot in neonatal preparations, including the elegant data of Fast and Kléber17 in neonatal cell cultures. We therefore considered that their published optical action potentials provided an excellent opportunity for an initial experimental test of our hypothesis. Our analysis of their data also provided a rigorous test of the phase-plane analysis method to ensure that the deviations from an exponential rise of Vm foot we found in working myocardium were not the result of experimental artifact. That is, there were concave deviations from a linear (exponential) phase-plane trajectory of Vm foot during LP in ventricular muscle, and these deviations should not (and did not13 ) occur in the optical action potentials that Fast and Kléber17 had recorded in neonatal cell cultures.
Roth11 suggests that a good experiment would be to remove
the superfusing fluid in the bath. We attempted that experiment but
could not achieve successful measurements. Although we were unable to
cover the preparations with oil in our large tissue bath (15 cm in
diameter), we lowered the level of the superfusate to the
surface of the tissue. When there was no fluid covering the surface,
beat-to-beat changes in the intracellular (
i) and
extracellular (
e) potential waveforms occurred, which
prevented stable measurements.
| Perfusate Effects |
|---|
|
|
|---|
e waveforms when conduction progressed in different
directions from a single stimulus site. The directionally dependent
changes in
e at the tissue surface were accounted for by
a "continuous" anisotropic model of directional differences in
effective axial resistance, which ignored
interstitial anisotropy in a preparation exposed to a large
volume conductor.18 We then collaborated with David
Geselowitz22 to evaluate the effects of the volume
conductor on
e at the surface of tissue with and without
interstitial anisotropy. The model of Geselowitz et
al,22 and the associated experimental measurements, showed
that as long as the level of the perfusate exceeded 1 mm
above the tissue surface, there was good agreement with the measured
e waveforms and the bidomain model predictions; ie,
interstitial anisotropy was not necessary to explain the
e waveforms.22 However, when the fluid
level decreased to <1 mm above the surface,
interstitial anisotropy became important; ie, the general
e wave shape was altered and the amplitude of the
waveforms increased considerably.22 Consequently, to
achieve extracellular measurements at the surface, we have maintained
an adequate volume conductor in our tissue bath experiments. | Waveform Variations Not Accounted for by Bath Effect |
|---|
|
|
|---|
e waveforms, which
are accounted for by a continuous anisotropic medium,18
there is notching of the
e first and second derivative
waveforms, and the notches become more frequent as the wavefront shifts
from LP to TP.20 Recent results with a 2-dimensional
discrete cellular model15 of uniform anisotropic
ventricular muscle produced good agreement with the
experimental
e, d
e/dt, and
d2
e/dt2 waveforms during LP,
oblique conduction, and TP.23 The
e
notching was found to be associated with more prominent conduction
delays between cells and groups of cells during TP than LP in mature
myocardium,15 23 ie, discontinuous
propagation.
At this point, therefore, it is important to separate the question as
to whether discontinuous propagation does or does not occur at a
microscopic level from Roths11 additional important
question as to how one can distinguish between the effects of cardiac
microstructure and the effects of the perfusing bath shown by bidomain
models on propagating waveforms. We have not questioned the validity of
the bidomain model predictions of the bath effects.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Rather, we found that the experimental variations in
max and in the time course of Vm foot
" ... were not explained by computer simulations based on
bidomain models,"13 (p 1145) at least to the
present time.
max
On the basis of measurements in trabecula and
papillary muscles from ferret hearts, in 1985 Suenson24
reported that differences in resistance of the medium to which the
tissue surface was exposed produces curved propagating wavefronts
beneath the surface. He noted that when a wavefront deviates from a
plane wave, the leading cells will be loaded electrically by the
lagging neighboring cells. He also extended the interpretation of his
results about curvature beneath the surface (along the z
axis) to the x-y plane of the tissue surface by noting that
"the effects of a curved wavefront may represent an
alternative explanation of the findings [directional differences in
max and
foot] of Spach et al.
(1981)12 who introduced the theory of discontinuous
propagation in dog myocardium ...."24 (p
89).
Suenson was correct, given that, at that time, we had not
considered the effects of the curvature of wavefronts in the
x-y plane (along the surface) at a macroscopic size scale.
Therefore, we challenged our 1981 data12 by performing
detailed measurements of
max for conditions under
which there should be no x-y plane curvature effects. We
produced "4-way conduction" of macroscopic plane waves at each
microelectrode impalement site; ie, propagation occurred in both
directions along the long axis of the fibers and in both directions
along the transverse axis.25 The results showed that mean
TP
max was significantly greater than mean LP
max, as we had originally found.12 We
concluded, therefore, that our
max results were not
explained by curvature of wavefronts.
The chronological appearance of "new" information based on
bidomain models now becomes pertinent. Although in 1978
Tung26 formalized in a bidomain model the mathematical
representation of the separate intracellular and
interstitial spaces as a single interpenetrating domain,
the powerful applications using mathematical representations of
this model to in vitro measurements (eg, virtual
cathode27 ) did not appear until after our 1981
paper.12 Since then, a number of model results have
demonstrated the effects of the perfusing bath on propagating
depolarization.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 All of the bidomain models that we
know of predict the following fixed relationships between
max and Vm foot: (1) at the surface, or
at a specific depth below the surface,
max and the
shape of Vm foot are constant during propagation along any
given axis of conduction, and 2) when
max decreases,
the rate of rise of Vm foot decreases (and vice versa).
In contrast to the bidomain model predictions of fixed values of
max along a given axis of propagation, our 4-way
conduction analysis showed that the values of
max were different from cell to cell during LP (93
to 139 V/s) and TP (110 to 181 V/s), and at a few sites TP
max was less than LP
max.25 That these considerable
variations along the same axis of conduction were not measurement
artifact, or due to the perfusing bath, was indicated by fact that the
absolute values of LP
max and TP
max at the same impalement site varied independently
of each other (some of the lowest values of LP
max
occurred at the same site as the highest TP
max
values). On the other hand, one might argue that the considerable
cell-to-cell
max variation along the same axis of
conduction was influenced by the tip of the microelectrode penetrating
to different depths beneath the surface at different sites, which could
produce different
max values according to bidomain
model predictions.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 However, when we maintained the
microelectrode tip in a fixed position (ie, no change in its depth),
max changed considerably at the same site when the
direction of conduction was reversed 180 degrees during LP. Similarly,
prominent
max changes occurred at the same site when
conduction was reversed 180 degrees during TP.
Thus, undulating values of
max occur in any
given direction of propagation, and it is the average
max value that is larger during TP than
LP.15 25 This anisotropic feature of
max is explained by variations in cellular loading
that generate variations in
max that are dependent
on the complex distribution of ri discontinuities produced
by the gap junctions and cellular boundaries in the path of an
advancing excitation wave.15
Vm Foot
Because there had been no detailed experimental
analysis of the time course of Vm foot during
anisotropic propagation, we performed a similar 4-way conduction
analysis of Vm foot in which we used phase-plane
analysis.13 Although the average values of
foot were greater during LP than TP, as found
originally,12 different sites demonstrated variable
deviations from a linear (exponential) Vm foot trajectory
during both LP and TP. Quite importantly,
max and
Vm foot varied independently of one another. We therefore
considered the major point established by the experimental results to
be that " ... electrical loading due the microstructure of
working myocardium can independently alter
max or the foot of the action
potential."13 (p 1159). This experimental result
is different from the predictions of continuous medium theory, as well
as the bidomain model predictions for the effects of the perfusing bath
as done to date.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
To explain these results, several resistive models17 28 29 30 31 (including our two-dimensional cellular model15 ) were evaluated but discarded. None of the models of resistive discontinuities produced deviations from a linear phase-plane trajectory of Vm at any site for all directions of conduction. On the basis of the measurements by Crone and Olesen32 and Oleson and Crone33 of the passive properties of cerebral capillaries, we then considered that the capillaries provided a structure in interstitial space for electrotonic interactions with the active myocytes. This structural arrangement is similar to that in the model of Medvinskii and Pertsov14 of electrical field interactions between active and inactive cardiac fibers. Thus, we hypothesized that the microstructure that could produce an effect as observed in the data was that of the capillaries.
Because the perfusing bath conditions were the same for all of our experiments, we consider the following to provide experimental support13 for the capillary hypothesis, rather than for the effects of the perfusing bath, as the explanation of our experimental Vm foot results.
(1) The magnitude of the concave deviations from linearity in the phase-plane trajectory of Vm foot varied considerably at different sites during LP. During TP, 30% of the impalement sites demonstrated an initial slur in the trajectory of Vm foot, whereas 70% of the sites had a linear Vm foot trajectory. These directionally different variations were accounted for in our 2-domain model results by known variations in capillary density and the variations we measured in the size of interstitial space (see Fig. 9 in Reference 1313 ). That is, the greater the density of capillaries and the smaller the size of interstitial space, the greater the deviation from a linear Vm foot trajectory.13
(2) In adult canine working myocardium, the concave deviations from linearity during LP were greater in ventricular than in atrial muscle (see Table 1 in Reference 1313 ). Our subsequent analysis has shown that the density of capillaries is significantly greater (P<0.001) in adult canine ventricular muscle than in atrial muscle bundles (ie, number of capillaries adjacent to each myocyte). This morphological result is consistent with that of Ludwig.34
(3) Neonatal ventricular muscle produced the most prominent concave deviations from a linear trajectory of Vm foot that we encountered; ie, the maximum difference from linearity during Vm foot was greater in neonatal than in adult ventricular muscle (P<0.02).13 Neonatal ventricular myocardium has the highest density of capillaries that occurs during any time interval from early life to adulthood.35 36
(4) The relationship between the average values of
max during LP and TP are different in neonatal than
adult canine ventricular muscle. That is, in contrast to
adult ventricular muscle, in neonatal
ventricular muscle the mean value of LP
max is not significantly different from mean TP
max.13 16 However, at a macroscopic
level the LP/TP velocity ratios are the same in neonatal and adult
canine ventricular muscle.16 It is difficult
to understand how the same bath effects could produce different adult
and neonatal patterns in
max, in addition to the
differences in Vm foot, in preparations that are normal
with similar uniform anisotropic properties and the same LP/TP velocity
ratio at a macroscopic level. On the other hand, our recent results
show that growth effects with associated increases in cell size, along
with remodeling of the cellular distribution of gap junctions from
birth to maturity, can explain the different neonatal and adult
anisotropic
max patterns at a microscopic level in
the presence of the same neonatal-adult LP/TP velocity ratios at a
macroscopic level.16
(5) We encountered other trajectories with atypical phase-plane
trajectories of Vm foot that are described, but not
illustrated, in our 1998 article.13 Figure 1
shows an example of the unusual
Vm foot shape changes we encountered at a single site when
LP conduction was reversed along the long axis of the fibers. In a
left-to-right direction (Figure 1
, left), there was the usual concave
deviation from a linear trajectory of Vm foot. However,
when the direction of conduction was reversed along the same axis, the
trajectory of Vm foot changed to a convex shape (Figure 1
, right).
|
We have not been able to account for this behavior of Vm
foot by branching,28 by any model of internal resistance
(ri) discontinuities,15 17 29 30 31 or by an
effect of the perfusing bath.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 However, in our
morphological studies of serial sections viewed rapidly (in motion)
with computer displays, abrupt changes (discontinuities) in the size of
interstitial space became apparent without apparent changes
in the distribution of the gap junctions or density of the
capillaries.13 When we included an abrupt change in the
size of interstitial space (ie, an abrupt change in
interstitial resistance) in our 2-domain model with
capillaries,13 the model results (Figure 2
) were in good agreement with the
experimental results shown in Figure 1
. Contrariwise, when the
capillaries were removed from the 2-domain model, both the concave and
convex shapes of the trajectory of Vm foot disappeared and
the Vm foot trajectory was linear at all sites during
conduction across the ris discontinuity.
|
| Conclusions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
max and the shape of
Vm foot that thus far have been explained only by specific
features of the documented natural architecture of cardiac bundles.
However, because of the relative paucity of available information about
the effects of different components of cardiac microstructure, both
Roths11 admonition and our results emphasize the need
for future study of variations in the depolarization shape of cardiac
action potentials and their cause.
The results presented here provide an evolving picture
that suggests that resistive discontinuities primarily affect
max, and an additional capacitive component due to
capillaries in interstitial space primarily affects
Vm foot. Therefore, the results emphasize that there are
yet important, unexplored resistive discontinuities at a microscopic
level. These include spatial variations in the size of
interstitial space13 and the role of cellular
scaling (effects of cell size)16 when changes occur in the
cellular and multicellular distribution of gap junctions during
remodeling of mature myocardium into structural substrates
that are arrhythmogenic.21 38
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received December 2, 1999; accepted December 30, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
max reflects both membrane
properties and the load presented by adjoining cells.
Am J Physiol. 1992;263:H1855H1863.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. J. Kocica, A. F. Corno, F. Carreras-Costa, M. Ballester-Rodes, M. C. Moghbel, C. N.C. Cueva, V. Lackovic, V. I. Kanjuh, and F. Torrent-Guasp The helical ventricular myocardial band: global, three-dimensional, functional architecture of the ventricular myocardium Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., April 1, 2006; 29(Suppl_1): S21 - S40. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. L. Trew, B. J. Caldwell, G. B. Sands, D. A. Hooks, D. C.-S. Tai, T. M. Austin, I. J. LeGrice, A. J. Pullan, and B. H. Smaill Cardiac electrophysiology and tissue structure: bridging the scale gap with a joint measurement and modelling paradigm Exp Physiol, March 1, 2006; 91(2): 355 - 370. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Libbus, X. Wan, and D. S. Rosenbaum Electrotonic load triggers remodeling of repolarizing current Ito in ventricle Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol, May 1, 2004; 286(5): H1901 - H1909. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Circulation Research Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2000 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |