Cellular Biology |
From the Department of Cell Biology (S.L.H., R.Z., Z.S., E.A.P., J.C.M., D.S., S.N.M., C.M., H.F.H., H.M.A.-S.), the Department of Cardiology (S.L.H.), and the Center for Surgery Research (A.C.), Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio, and the Chemistry Department (S.L.H., W.W., Y.C., H.F.H.), Cleveland State University, Cleveland, Ohio.
Correspondence to Stanley L. Hazen, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Lerner Research Institute, Department of Cell Biology, 9500 Euclid Ave, NC-10, Cleveland, OH 44195. E-mail hazens{at}ccf.org
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: nitrotyrosine atherosclerosis lipid peroxidation nitric oxide
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Multiple cells present in the vasculature (eg, macrophages, endothelial cells) are capable of generating nitric oxide (NO), a long-lived free radical with potent biological activities.8 NO is a weak reducing agent and does not react with most biological targets; however, a variety of reactive nitrogen species derived from NO are powerful oxidants, and they may contribute to oxidative damage.9 10 11 The cellular sources of reactive nitrogen species in atherosclerotic tissues is not established. It is generally assumed, however, that monocytes play a role in their production. Monocytes can be stimulated with various cytokines and vasoactive hormones to produce NO by upregulating expression of the inducible isoform of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) (reviewed in Reference 1212 ). Monocytes also undergo a respiratory burst after activation by a variety of agonists, producing reduced oxygen species such as superoxide (O2-) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2).13 14 Hence, it has been concluded that monocytes may generate peroxynitrite (ONOO-), a potent nitrating oxidant formed by the interaction of NO and O2-.5 6 9
Despite the fact that monocytes are thought to play an essential role in both atherogenesis15 and the generation of reactive nitrogen species in vascular tissues,1 2 3 4 16 17 the chemical pathways available to monocytes for generating NO-derived oxidants have not yet been directly examined. Indeed, no reports to date demonstrate that monocytes can promote the nitration of free or protein-bound tyrosine residues. Moreover, enhanced NO production by peritoneal macrophages16 or from an exogenous source18 19 has been reported to inhibit rather than augment the extent of LDL lipid peroxidation. Thus, direct examination of the pathways available to monocytes for generating reactive nitrogen species and the characterization of the conditions under which they participate in protein and lipid modification must be addressed.
Studies thus far into the pathways available for LDL modification
by reactive nitrogen species have relied primarily on in vitro chemical
systems, neutrophils, and exogenous NO
generating systems. On the basis of these studies, at least 3 distinct
pathways for generating reactive nitrogen species have been suggested.
The first involves formation of ONOO- through
the interaction of NO and
O2-.9 The
exposure of LDL to ONOO- results in the
nitration of apolipoprotein B-100 (apo B-100) tyrosine
residues,6 the initiation of lipid
peroxidation,20 21 and the depletion of lipid-soluble
antioxidants.22 23 The incubation of LDL with millimolar
concentrations of ONOO- results in lipoprotein
aggregation and conversion into a high uptake form for
macrophages.7 24 In the presence of
CO2, ONOO- forms a more
potent nitrating intermediate, presumably nitrosoperoxocarbonate
(ONOOCO2-).25 At
physiological concentrations of
CO2, the yield of
ONOO--mediated nitration reactions is increased,
apparently through formation of this adduct (reviewed in Reference 2626 ).
The formation of ONOO- is shown in the following
equation:
![]() | (1) |
Two alternative pathways for generating reactive nitrogen species were recently described; they each involve MPO, a protein secreted by neutrophils and monocytes.27 28 29 30 Immunohistochemical studies demonstrate that MPO is abundant in human atherosclerotic lesions.31 LDL recovered from human atheromas is enriched in chlorotyrosine, a specific product of MPO-generated hypochlorous acid (HOCl).32 Antibodies specific for nitrotyrosine recognize epitopes in human atheroma that colocalize with mononuclear phagocytic cells,5 which are similar to MPO.31 Recent studies demonstrate that isolated MPO can use nitrite (NO2-), a major end product of NO metabolism,11 33 as a substrate to nitrate protein tyrosine residues7 28 29 and initiate lipid peroxidation.7 34
LDL exposed to the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system is converted into a high-uptake form for macrophages,
leading to cholesterol deposition and foam cell
formation,7 essential steps in atherogenesis. The reactive
nitrogen species formed during MPO-catalyzed oxidation of
NO2- have not yet been
identified, but nitrogen dioxide
(NO2), the one-electron
oxidation product of NO2-,
has been implicated.28 Finally, MPO may also indirectly
generate a nitrating intermediate through the secondary oxidation of
NO2- with HOCl, presumably
forming nitryl chloride (NO2Cl).27
Exposure of LDL to NO2Cl causes lipoprotein
aggregation and conversion into a phagocytosable particle for
macrophages.35 Despite the ability of monocytes to
undergo a respiratory burst, to generate
NO, and to secrete MPO when
activated, direct evidence that monocytes can generate reactive
nitrogen species that promote LDL nitration and lipid peroxidation is
lacking. Equations for the chemical reactions discussed above
follow:
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
In the present study, we examined the various chemical pathways available to monocytes for generating reactive nitrogen species. Mechanisms for the monocyte-dependent formation of nitrating intermediates and characterization of the ability of these distinct pathways to promote LDL protein nitration and initiate LDL lipid peroxidation are presented. Finally, we examined the role of NO production rates on the relative contribution of distinct pathways in activated monocytes for promoting apo B-100 nitration and LDL lipid peroxidation.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
(PGF2
), and
8-epi-[2H4]PGF2
standards were purchased from Cayman Chemical, and
[3H]arachidonate (40 mCi/mmol) was
obtained from ICN Pharmaceutical, Inc. Organic solvents
(high-performance liquid chromatography
[HPLC]grade) were obtained from Fisher Chemical Company. Catalase
(bovine liver, thymol-free) and glucose oxidase (grade II) were
purchased from Boehringer Mannheim. All other reagents were
obtained from Sigma Chemical Co, unless otherwise specified.
Methods
General Procedures
All buffers and media were treated with Chelex-100 resin
(Bio-Rad) and supplemented with diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid
(DTPA) to remove trace levels of potential redox-active transition
metal ions. Protein content was determined by the Markwell-modified
Lowry protein assay36 using bovine serum albumin
as the standard. The concentration of reagent
H2O2 was determined
spectrophotometrically (
240=39.4
mol-1 · L · cm-1;
Reference 3737 ).
NO2-/NO3-
production by human monocytes was monitored by the Griess
assay.38
Oxidation Reactions
Human monocytes were isolated from the peripheral
blood of healthy volunteers after obtaining informed consent. All
protocols were approved by the Cleveland Clinic Foundation
Institutional Review Committee and were in accordance with
institutional guidelines. Preliminary studies demonstrated that
monocytes isolated by methods that use adhesion/washing steps contained
significantly less MPO per cell (presumably because of premature
degranulation during the isolation procedure). Human
peripheral blood monocytes used for this study were
therefore isolated by elutriation.39 Monocytes were
incubated at 37°C under 95% air and 5% CO2 in
medium A
(Ca2+/Mg2+/phenol-free
Hanks balanced salt solution [Gibco Life Technologies] supplemented
with 50 µmol/L L-arginine and 200 µmol/L DTPA [pH 7.4
final]) containing 0.2 mg/mL LDL protein in the presence or absence of
NaNO2 (0 to 50 µmol/L, as indicated in the
figure legends).
Monocytes (1x106 cells/mL) were activated with 200 nmol/L phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) and maintained in suspension by gentle mixing every 5 minutes. After 2 hours, reactions were stopped by creating cell pellets (by centrifugation [2000g] at 4°C) and adding 50 µmol/L butylated hydroxytoluene to the supernatants. LDL oxidation products were then assayed in supernatants as described below. In some experiments, monocytes were activated in the presence of an exogenous NO source by adding Z-[N-(3-aminopropyl)-N-(n-propyl)amino]diazen-1-ium-1,2-diolate (PAPA NONOate, Alexis Corp) 1 minute after the addition of PMA. Initial concentrations of the NO donor were selected on the basis of calculated rates of NO flux, assuming that PAPA NONOate spontaneously releases 2 mol of NO per mol of donor molecule, with a t1/2 of 15 minutes at 37°C (pH 7.4).40 Actual rates of NO flux were then determined spectrophotometrically by the reaction of NO with oxyhemoglobin41 under the same conditions used for experiments but in the absence of any added cells. To maintain a final pH of 7.4 during experiments with PAPA NONOate, incubations were performed in medium B (medium A containing only 100 mmol/L NaCl and supplemented with 20 mmol/L sodium phosphate).
Pilot experiments revealed that detectable levels of
F2-isoprostanes were generated by monocytes in
the absence of added NO2-, but
only at a level
20% of that observed in the presence of
NO2-. This was presumably due
to prostaglandin endoperoxide synthase
activity, because the reaction was inhibited by aspirin and
dexamethasone and not inhibited by superoxide dismutase
(SOD), aminotriazole, or butylated hydroxytoluene. Thereafter, in all
experiments in which F2-isoprostane
production was measured, the contribution of
prostaglandin endoperoxide synthase-1 and
-2 to eicosanoid production was suppressed by including aspirin
(10 µg sodium salicylate/mL) and dexamethasone (2
µmol/L), respectively, in reaction mixtures before monocyte
stimulation.42
Sample Preparation and Mass Spectrometric Analyses
Nitrotyrosine content was determined by stable isotope dilution
gas chromatographymass spectrometry (GC/MS) on a
Finnigin Voyager quadrupole GC/MS equipped with a chemical ionization
probe.
3-[13C6]nitrotyrosine was
synthesized and used as an internal standard, as previously
described.6 Briefly, reactions were terminated by forming
cell pellets and adding butylated hydroxytoluene. Lipids and
salts were removed by extraction with a single-phase solvent mixture of
H2O:water-washed diethyl ether:methanol (1:3:7,
vol:vol:vol).43 Internal standards were then added,
samples were hydrolyzed with HCl, and the nitrotyrosine content in
amino acid hydrolysates was determined after reduction to amino
tyrosine as an n-propyl, per heptafluorobutyryl
derivative.44 Nitrotyrosine content was normalized to the
content of tyrosine determined by stable isotope dilution
GC/MS45 using
[2H4]-labeled tyrosine as
the standard. Under the conditions used, no significant
intrapreparative formation of nitrotyrosine, which was routinely
assessed in each sample by determining the
3-[2H3]-nitrotyrosine
present, occurred.
For 9-hydroxy-10,12-octadecadienoate/9-hydroperoxy-10,12-octadecadienoate acid (9-H[P]ODE) and F2-isoprostane determinations, hydroperoxides in reaction mixtures were reduced to their corresponding stable hydroxides during extraction using a modified Dole procedure in which the reducing agent, triphenylphosphine, was present.46 These conditions also inhibited artifactual formation of F2-isoprostanes and oxidized lipids.47 Lipids were dried under N2 and resuspended in isopropanol (2 mL); then, fatty acids were released by base hydrolysis with 1N sodium hydroxide (2 mL) at room temperature under N2 for 90 minutes. The samples were acidified (pH 3.0) with 2N HCl, known amounts of internal standards were added, and free fatty acids were extracted twice with hexane (5 mL). The content of 9-H(P)ODEs and F2-isoprostanes were then determined by HPLC with online tandem mass spectrometric (LC/MS/MS) analysis. Control experiments using [3H]arachidonate confirmed that no detectable formation of [3H]-labeled 9-H(P)ODE or F2-isoprostanes occurred under the conditions used for sample preparation.
LC/MS/MS analyses were performed on a Quatro II triple
quadruple mass spectrometer (Micromass, Inc) interfaced with an HP 1100
HPLC (Hewlett Packard). F2-isoprostanes were
quantified by stable isotope dilution mass spectrometry using online
reverse-phase LC/MS/MS with
8-epi-[2H4]PGF2
as the standard.48 For 9-HODE analyses, lipid
extracts generated after base hydrolysis of reduced lipids (above) were
dried under N2 and reconstituted in 100 µL of
methanol. An aliquot of the mixture was then injected on an Ultrasphere
ODS C18 column (4.6x250 mm, 5 µm, Beckman
Instruments), equilibrated, and run under isocratic conditions
at 1 mL/min using methanol:H2O, (85:15, vol/vol)
as the solvent. The column eluent was split (930 µL/min to UV
detector and 70 µL/min to mass detector) and analyzed by the
mass spectrometer. The LC/MS/MS analyses of 9-HODE and
F2-isoprostanes in column effluents were
performed using electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry in the
negative-ion mode with multiple-reaction monitoring and monitoring the
transitions at mass per unit charge (m/z) 295
171 for 9-HODE,
m/z 353
309 for F2-isoprostanes, and m/z
357
313 for
[2H4]PGF2
.
The endogenous content of 9-H(P)ODE in samples was
initially determined by the method of standard additions using known
amounts of authentic 9-HODE added to samples. Quantification in
subsequent experiments was done using external calibration curves
constructed with authentic 9-HODE after preliminary LC/MS/MS
experiments demonstrating results identical to those obtained by the
method of standard additions.
Statistics
Statistical analyses were done using a paired Students
t test. For all hypotheses, the significance level was 0.05.
When multiple comparisons were made, a Bonferroni correction to the
significance criterion for each test was done.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
120 minutes (data not shown).
Tyrosine nitration and lipid peroxidation by monocytes required cell
activation and were inhibited by the presence of peroxidase
inhibitors (NaN3 and aminotriazole).
Moreover, adding catalase, but not heat-inactivated
catalase, effectively blocked nitrotyrosine, 9-H(P)ODE, and
F2-isoprostane production (Figure 1
|
Monocytes activated with
N-formyl-methionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine (100 nmol/L)
similarly demonstrated
NO2--dependent LDL tyrosine
nitration and lipid peroxidation, albeit at a level
6- to 8-fold
less (2 fmol
O2-/cell over a 2-hour
interval) than that observed with monocytes stimulated with PMA (12
fmol O2-/cell over a 2-hour
interval), which is consistent with the findings that both
O2- production and
MPO secretion are decreased in monocytes stimulated with this agonist.
Finally, the addition of methionine, a potent scavenger of chlorinating
oxidants like HOCl and NO2Cl, failed to
significantly attenuate the extent of tyrosine nitration and lipid
peroxidation induced by the activated monocytes (Figure 1
). These results suggest that secondary oxidation of
NO2- by HOCl (eg, Equation 3
) was not a significant pathway for reactive nitrogen species
formation by the activated monocytes.
Interestingly, adding either SOD or heat-inactivated SOD to
the reaction mixture did not attenuate protein nitration or lipid
peroxidation by the cells, suggesting that
O2- (and hence
ONOO-; Equation 1
) does not play a
direct role in LDL oxidation by human peripheral blood
monocytes under the conditions examined. Rather, adding SOD to the
activated cells resulted in a modest increase (
50%) in the
production of markers of lipid peroxidation (Figure 1
).
Control experiments suggested that SOD itself was not directly
promoting lipid peroxidation because the addition of both SOD and
peroxidase inhibitors (ie, NaN3,
NaCN, or aminotriazole) to cells activated in the presence of
NO2- resulted in no significant
formation of lipid oxidation products (data not shown). The
mechanism(s) responsible for the increased extent of lipid peroxidation
observed in the presence of SOD are unknown, but they may reflect the
prevention of O2--dependent
conversion of MPO into an inactive form (ie, Compound
III)49 or the enhanced conversion of superoxide
(O2-) into the MPO
substrate
H2O2.50
Alternatively, increased levels of lipid peroxidation with the addition
of SOD could result from excess scavenging of the
O2- radical, preventing it
from terminating chain-propagating reactions and leading to a net
increase in lipid peroxidation via increased chain
length.51 Collectively, these results suggest that freshly
isolated human peripheral blood monocytes generate reactive
nitrogen species primarily through a peroxidase-,
H2O2- and
NO2--dependent pathway (ie, the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
pathway; Equation 2
).
Monocytes Use Physiologically Relevant
Levels of NO2- to Nitrate Apo B-100 Tyrosine
Residues and Initiate LDL Lipid Peroxidation
To further examine the physiological relevance
of NO2- oxidation by monocytes
as a potential mechanism for the modification of protein and lipid
targets in vivo, we activated cells in the presence of LDL and
concentrations of NO2- similar
to those observed in vivo (ie,
50 µmol/L; reviewed in
Reference 2828 ) and then monitored the extent of tyrosine nitration and
lipid peroxidation by stable isotope dilution GC/MS and LC/MS/MS,
respectively. In the presence of normal plasma levels of
NO2- (ie,
5 µmol/L),
monocyte activation resulted in LDL nitration and lipid peroxidation.
Moreover, nitration of apo B-100 tyrosine residues (Figure 2
) and peroxidation of LDL lipids (Figure 3
) increased progressively as a function
of NO2- concentration over a
pathophysiologically relevant range. Adding
catalase to the reaction mixtures before cell activation inhibited
protein and lipid modification by the reactive nitrogen intermediate(s)
formed during monocyte-dependent oxidation of
NO2-. Thus, monocyte activation
in vivo will likely produce nitrating intermediates at both normal and
pathophysiologically relevant concentrations of
NO2- through the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system.
|
|
Monocytes Generate NO-Derived Oxidants
One striking feature of the results described thus far was that we
could find no evidence that isolated monocytes generate nitrating
intermediates through the formation of ONOO-
(Equation 1
), because both nitrotyrosine formation and lipid
peroxidation required the addition of
NO2- to the media (Figures 1 through 3![]()
![]()
). This likely reflects the limited
capacity of freshly isolated peripheral blood monocytes to
generate NO, the brief time period used
for LDL incubation with monocytes (ie, 2 hours, the approximate
duration of O2- formation
after a PMA-stimulated respiratory burst), and the presence of metal
chelators in cell culture media to prevent lipid peroxidation mediated
by trace levels of redox-active transition metal ions. Indeed, we were
unable to detect any endogenous rate of NO
production (or
NO2-/NO3-
accumulation) in human monocytes freshly isolated from
peripheral blood, with or without phorbol ester activation,
under the conditions and time course (2 hours) used. To more fully
explore the chemical mechanisms available to monocytes for generating
reactive nitrogen species, we performed a series of experiments in
which monocytes were activated in the presence of an exogenous
NO-generating system, PAPA
NONOate.40 These conditions were expected to more closely
mimic a physiological mechanism for
NO2- formation and to provide
an environment in which monocyte-generated
O2- might react with
NO before it dismutates into the MPO
substrate H2O2.
Although monocytes activated in the absence of the
NO donor failed to nitrate apo B-100
tyrosine residues or to produce detectable levels of the products
of lipid peroxidation (ie, 9H(P)ODE and
F2-isoprostanes), cells stimulated in the
presence of a continuous NO source
readily promoted LDL protein (Figure 4
)
and lipid (Figure 5
) modification.
Protein nitration and lipid peroxidation by monocytes required cell
activation, which is consistent with a requirement for reduced
oxygen species (O2- and/or
H2O2) for lipoprotein
oxidation (data not shown). At higher fluxes of
NO, the overall extent of nitrotyrosine
formation and lipid peroxidation diminished (Figures 4
and 5
). Taken together, the present results demonstrate that
activated monocytes generate
NO-derived oxidants that can damage
protein and lipid targets.
|
|
Monocytes Use Distinct Pathways for Generating
NO-Derived Oxidants
At low rates of NO flux, LDL protein
nitration (Figure 6
, top) and lipid
peroxidation (Figure 7
, top) were
inhibited by either catalase or azide. In contrast, under these
conditions, the addition of either HOCl scavengers (eg, methionine or
N
-acetyl lysine) or SOD failed to significantly attenuate
nitrotyrosine or 9-H(P)ODE production (Figure 6
, bottom,
and Figure 7
, bottom, respectively). These results suggest that
at low rates of NO flux, LDL modification
by monocytes occurs through a pathway requiring
H2O2 and MPO (ie, the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system; Equation 2
). They also suggest that monocyte-mediated
nitration and lipid peroxidation reactions at low levels of
NO flux do not proceed through the
intermediary formation of HOCl or ONOO- (ie,
Equations 1
, and 3
).
|
|
At high rates of NO flux, LDL protein
nitration (Figure 6
, top) and lipid peroxidation (Figure 7
, top) by activated monocytes became increasingly less
sensitive to inhibition by either catalase or azide. These results
suggest that the relative contribution of the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system toward the generation of reactive nitrogen species by monocytes
diminishes under these conditions. Although adding methionine partially
attenuated the extent of nitrotyrosine and 9-H(P)ODE produced at high
levels of NO flux, the mechanism does not
seem to be due to the consumption of NO2Cl or
HOCl. Adding a primary amine (N
-acetyl lysine) that also reacts
rapidly with reactive chlorinating species like HOCl and
NO2Cl to form monochloramines,52 53
agents which do not promote the secondary oxidation of
NO2-,29 failed to
inhibit either nitrotyrosine production or LDL lipid
peroxidation by activated monocytes (Figure 6
, bottom,
and Figure 7
, bottom, respectively). Taken together, the
present results indicate that monocytes use distinct pathways for
generating NO-derived oxidants.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The present studies demonstrated that monocytes use distinct
mechanisms for generating reactive nitrogen intermediates. They also
demonstrated that the environment in which monocyte activation occurs
(eg, level of NO) influences the relative
contribution that distinct oxidation pathways play in contributing to
protein nitration and lipid peroxidation. On the basis of the results
from the present report and prior published studies, we generated
the following model (Figure 8
) of
pathways available to monocytes for promoting LDL modification by
reactive nitrogen species. On activation, the NADPH oxidase complex of
monocytes forms O2-, which
both spontaneously and enzymatically (through SOD) dismutates to form
H2O2.13
Concomitantly, monocyte activation leads to the secretion of MPO into
the extracellular compartment (and into the phagolysosomal compartment;
not shown).53 Under conditions of relatively low levels of
NO flux, the primary pathway used by
monocytes for generating reactive nitrogen intermediates is through
MPO/H2O2-catalyzed
oxidation of NO2- (Figure 8
, pathway A). The ability of monocytes to use this pathway is
strongly supported by the demonstration that both activated
monocytes (this study) and isolated MPO7 use
physiological concentrations of
NO2- to nitrate apo B-100
tyrosine residues and initiate LDL lipid peroxidation. The ability of
MPO inhibitors (NaN3, NaCN, and
aminotriazole) and H2O2
scavengers (catalase) to block nitrotyrosine (Figures 1
and 6
), F2-isoprostane (Figure 1
), and
9-H(P)ODE (Figures 1
and 7
) formation by cells
activated in the presence of either
NO2- or
NO are consistent with a primary
role for the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
pathway in the formation of nitrating oxidants by monocytes. The
reactive nitrogen species (NOx) formed by the
MPO-catalyzed oxidation of NO2-
has not yet been identified. Both one-electron (nitrogen
dioxide)11 28 and two-electron
(NO2+ or
ONOO-)11 54 oxidation products
have been suggested as potential nitrating intermediates formed during
the peroxidase-catalyzed oxidation of
NO2-. Further studies to
identify the nitrating intermediate(s) produced during MPO-catalyzed
oxidation of NO2- are
warranted.
|
The present study also confirms that another pathway for monocytes
to generate reactive nitrogen species is through the formation of
ONOO- (Figure 8
, pathway C). Although
monocytes from freshly isolated human peripheral blood
failed to generate detectable levels of nitrotyrosine or lipid
oxidation products in LDL exposed to activated cells only,
monocyte stimulation in the presence of high fluxes of
NO resulted in LDL nitration and lipid
peroxidation. The ability of SOD and methionine (which scavenge
O2- and
ONOO-, respectively) to inhibit nitrotyrosine
and 9-H(P)ODE production (Figures 6
and 7
,
bottom) and the lack of significant inhibition in the presence of MPO
inhibitors or catalase (Figures 6
and 7
, top)
support a role for ONOO- (Figure 8
, pathway C), and not the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system (Figure 8
, pathway A), in promoting LDL modification
under these conditions. Thus, under conditions of high
NO flux,
O2- interaction with
NO forming ONOO-
(ie, Equation 1
) seems to account for a significant portion of
the reactive nitrogen species formed by activated
monocytes.
It is interesting to note that the overall yields of nitration and
lipid peroxidation dropped at higher fluxes of
NO (Figures 4
and 5
).
Several mechanism(s) may account for these results. One likely reason
is that NO may partially act as an
antioxidant under these conditions by scavenging reactive intermediates
though radical-radical interactions.55 Alternatively, the
decreased formation of nitrotyrosine and lipid oxidation products
may be due to lower overall yields with ONOO-
compared with the
MPO-H2O2-NO2-
system. Another intriguing possibility is that high levels of
NO flux could potentially attenuate
protein nitration and lipid peroxidation by inhibiting critical heme
proteins involved in O2-
formation (eg, NADPH oxidase) or reactive nitrogen species formation
(eg, MPO) (H.M. Abu-Soud and S.L. Hazen, unpublished data,
1999).
We were unable to detect any endogenous rate of NO production (or NO2-/NO3- accumulation) in human monocytes freshly isolated from peripheral blood, with or without phorbol ester activation, under the conditions and time course used. Similarly, replacement of L-arginine in the media with L-nitro-arginine methyl ester, an inhibitor of NOS, had no effect on the level of oxidation products generated by activated monocytes in the presence or absence of exogenous NO2- or NO (data not shown). These results are consistent with the low levels of the inducible isoform of NOS found in freshly isolated human monocytes; however, in the presence of a variety of cytokines and vasoactive hormones, human monocytes can generate NO after the upregulation of NOS gene expression.12 Thus, both monocytes and endothelium may serve as NO sources in vivo and contribute to ONOO- (and NO2-) formation.
Although the secondary oxidation of
NO2- by MPO-generated HOCl is
reported as a mechanism for MPO- and neutrophil-mediated nitrotyrosine
formation,27 29 the present results failed to
demonstrate a role for this pathway (Figure 8
, pathway B) in the
monocyte-dependent formation of nitrating agents. Specifically, neither
the extent of apo B-100 nitrotyrosine formation nor the content of
F2-isoprostanes and 9-H(P)ODE formed during
exposure of LDL to activated monocytes and
NO2- was blocked by the
addition of the HOCl scavenger methionine (Figure 1
). Moreover,
monocyte activation in the presence of an
NO donor and N
-acetyl lysine, which
rapidly reacts with HOCl and NO2Cl to form
monochloramines, failed to inhibit LDL nitration and lipid peroxidation
(Figures 6
and 7
, bottom). Whether this pathway
contributes to reactive nitrogen species formation by monocytes
activated under alternative conditions remains unknown.
An important consideration is the concentrations of
NO2-,
NO, and
CO2-HCO3-
used in the present study. Although the actual levels of
NO2- present in tissues
such as the arterial intima are not known,
NO2- levels of
5
µmol/L are normally present in plasma, and levels as high as
50 µmol/L have been observed in numerous biological fluids
during inflammation (See Reference 2828 and references therein). Thus,
the present results demonstrate that monocytes use biologically
relevant levels of NO2- to
promote protein nitration and lipid peroxidation (Figures 2
and 3
). Similarly, a wide range of steady-state levels of
NO are observed (20 nmol/L to 2
µmol/L) in vivo.11
NO-dependent protein nitration and lipid
peroxidation were mediated by monocytes activated in the
presence of NO fluxes over this range
(Figures 4
and 5
). Finally, recent studies demonstrated
that the chemical reactivity and actions of
ONOO- are significantly influenced by
CO2-HCO3-
(reviewed in Reference 2626 ). Intra- and extracellular concentrations of
CO2 and
HCO3- in humans are typically 1
to 2 mmol/L and 7 to 25 mmol/L, respectively.56
At these levels, a significant portion of the reactivity of
ONOO- in solution is attributable to
ONOOCO2-.25 26 27 57
Although the levels of CO2 (5% gas phase) and
HCO2- in the media (4.2
mmol/L) used in these studies more closely mimic a biologically
relevant situation, the proximate oxidant in reactions mediated by the
product of NO and
O2- (Figure 8
, pathway C) is not easily established (ONOO-
versus ONOOCO2- or a
combination of the two).
A significant finding of the present study is the demonstration that alternative pathways to ONOO- formation can play a significantand even predominantrole in oxidative injury of biomolecules by monocyte-generated nitrating intermediates. One practical consequence is that efforts to block oxidative injury in vivo by NO-derived oxidants will require the use of distinct pharmacological agents that block distinct pathways. For example, agents such as SOD mimetics, which can compete with NO for O2- and inhibit ONOO- formation, may serve to paradoxically enhance nitration and lipid peroxidation reactions through the MPO-H2O2-NO2- pathway. It is known that nitrotyrosine is present in a variety of tissues and conditions. What remains is to determine the functional consequences of protein and lipid modification by nitrating oxidants in vivo and to identify which factors influence the relative contributions of various mechanisms for generating NO-derived oxidants during human health and disease.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received June 17, 1999; accepted September 8, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-tocopherol in human low-density
lipoprotein by the simultaneous generation of superoxide
and nitric oxide. FEBS Lett. 1993;326:199203.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
-tocopherol on the nitration of
-tocopherol by peroxynitrite. Arch Biochem
Biophys. 1999;363:333340.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
by human
monocytes: discriminate production by reactive oxygen species
and prostaglandin endoperoxide synthase-2.
J Biol Chem. 1996;271:89198924.