Original Contribution |
From the Departments of Internal Medicine (Cardiology) (Q.Q., L.K., Y.-T.Y., J.N.R.), Pharmacology (J.N.R.), and Biochemistry (Y.-T.Y.), Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tenn.
Correspondence to Jeffrey N. Rottman, Department of Pharmacology, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, 360 MRB II, Nashville, TN 37232. E-mail jeff.rottman{at}mcmail.vanderbilt.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: fatty acidbinding protein myocyte promoter region transgene
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
HFABP, the product of the FABP3 gene, is a member of a family of intracellular lipid-binding proteins whose gene structures are consistent with an origin by repeated gene duplication.5 These homologous, low molecular weight, soluble cytosolic proteins (identities ranging from 25% to 95%) are commonly named for the tissues from which they were first isolated. Members include the liver, intestinal, ileal, adipocyte, epidermal, retinal, and peripheral myelin lipid-binding proteins, and, more distantly, the cytosolic retinoic and retinol binding proteins.6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Germline deletion of the adipocyte fatty acidbinding protein (FABP) by homologous recombination has suggested a major role for this family member in the cellular and systemic regulation of metabolism.13
Differences in the level of the FABP3 gene product in different tissue types and variations in response to environmental stimuli have long been recognized.14 15 16 In general, mRNA and protein levels change in parallel, and patterns of distribution of mRNA and protein are similar in humans and other species.17 18 The highest relative expression occurs in the heart, with lower levels of expression in "slow" skeletal muscle. Lower but detectable levels of expression occur in "fast" skeletal muscle, the aorta, placenta, adrenal, ovary, and testis. The same gene is expressed in a highly regulated manner in the mammary gland, where it was initially termed mammary-derived growth inhibitor (MDGI).19 MDGI is barely detectable in the quiescent mammary gland but is dramatically upregulated with lactation.
The developmental distribution of HFABP has been evaluated in rats: HFABP was detectable in day 19 rat embryo hearts at 20% of adult levels, increased 3-fold to term, and continued to increase during the postnatal period until weaning.15 These changes parallel developmental increases in mitochondrial number, carnitine level, palmitoyl transferase activity, and ß-oxidative capacity. Hormonal milieu and exercise also modulate HFABP expression, with higher levels in females.20 Exercise training increases HFABP expression per gram of muscle in heart and skeletal muscle, as does chronic electrostimulation of fast-twitch muscle.21 22 23 Modest changes in HFABP occur with increased dietary-lipid contents.24 Hearts from diabetic rats show increased HFABP protein and mRNA, and these levels normalize on islet cell transplantation.25
The molecular basis for the tissue-specific and regulated expression of HFABP is not known. Although a number of genes expressed at high levels in the heart have been analyzed, the vast majority of these genes encode contractile proteins. The heart has a different substrate preference than most other tissues, abnormalities of metabolism are frequently an early change in many inherited and acquired abnormalities of heart function, and metabolic perturbations can themselves result in cardiomyopathy. The choice of substrate for energy metabolism can also alter the oxygen cost for ATP production,26 an important consideration in the presence of flow-limiting coronary perfusion. It is important and unknown whether similar mechanisms govern the expression of metabolic and contractile genes in the heart. The high levels of expression of HFABP in heart and the compact and highly informative promoter regions present in other FABPs prompted us to investigate transcriptional regulation of cardiac FABP.
We report that a 1.2 kb region of the 5'-flanking sequence of the HFABP gene is sufficient to direct cell-type specific expression in tissue culture and tissue-appropriate patterns of expression in transgenic mice. Comparison of orthologous human and mouse sequences demonstrates multiple regions of striking conservation within this short region. A completely conserved CArG-like element close to the TATA box constitutes a myocyte enhancerbinding factor 2 (MEF2) site on the basis of binding and transactivation. Although this site does not correspond to an established MEF2 consensus sequence, it can be recognized by a threshold relaxation of the probability weight matrix method. Other sites are likely to be important in factor-factor interactions that enhance specific expression and couple tissue-specific and metabolic regulation.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
[32P]-dCTP labeled
Kpn1-EcoR1 fragment of the rat HFABP cDNA (Dr
Jeff Gordon, Washington University School of Medicine), encompassing
nucleotides 69 to 447 of the coding region, was used to
screen 1x106 plaques of a
-EMBL3 human
placental genomic library (Stratagene) by hybridization. Clones H1 and
H5 were obtained, restriction maps generated, and inserts subcloned in
plasmid vectors for further analysis. Dideoxy chain termination
sequencing was performed on both strands with universal and specific
sequencing primers (DNA International); when necessary, nested
deletions were created according to the ExoIII/mung bean
nuclease method (Erase-a-base, Promega). Rescreening of this same
library together with an additional 6x105
plaques of a
-FIX II human lymphocyte genomic library (Stratagene)
with probes prepared from (1) the 266 bp intronic sequence at the
5'-end of clone H1, (2) the 331 bp from the 5'-end
(KpnI-NcoI) fragment of the rat HFABP cDNA, and
(3) a full-length human HFABP cDNA obtained from a
-ZAP II human
heart library (Stratagene) completed the genomic cloning. Six
additional overlapping clones (H8, H10, H11, H13, H14, and H15) were
obtained. A similar approach was used to clone the 5'-flanking sequence
of the mouse HFABP gene from a
FIX II mouse genomic library (129SV,
Stratagene).
HFABP Promoter Constructs
Constructs were derived from the human HFABP promoter. An
Xba1 site was introduced in the wild-type HFABP promoter at
+29 relative to the primary transcription start site by converting
CCTAGA to TCTAGA. Cassettes of 0.4 kb
(Sph1 site), 0.6 kb (Hind3), 1.2 kb
(Sph1), and 4.6 kb (Hind3) were cloned between
the Hind3 and Xba1 sites in the polylinker region of the promoterless
expression vectors pCAT-basic (Promega) and p0GH (Nichols Institute),
which created the chimeric expression plasmids
pCAT-HFABP0.4pCAT-HFABP4.6 and pGH-HFABP0.4pGH-HFABP4.6,
respectively.
For mutagenesis, the 0.4 kb HFABP promoter was cloned into pALTER-1 (Promega), and the mutation was introduced with the use of the Altered Sites II mutagenesis system (Promega) with the complementary oligonucleotide (change underlined): (-68) 5'-GCTCCCGAAATCGGAAGCCCCAG-3'. Dideoxy chain termination sequencing confirmed the presence of only the desired mutation.
Tissue Culture and Transfections
C2C12 and Sol8 cells, permanent murine cell lines of fast and
slow skeletal myocyte derivation, respectively, were maintained in 14%
FCS in DMEM in the presence of penicillin/streptomycin (growth media)
and passed at 80% confluence. Differentiation was induced with the
change to 4% heat-inactivated horse serum in DMEM
(differentiation media) and was visually monitored by the appearance of
multinucleated myotubes. Only cells with a low passage number were
used. CaCo-2 cells were maintained in 20% FCS in DMEM.
Primary ventricular myocytes were prepared from 1-day-old rat pups with the use of a procedure that has been previously shown to produce a >95% separation of myocytic and nonmyocytic cells.27 Spontaneous rhythmic contraction occurred within 12 hours in the myocytes.
Calcium phosphate coprecipitates or lipofectin were used for the transient and permanent transfections of Sol8, C2C12, and CaCo-2 cells. Primary cardiocytes were transfected with 30 µL of DOTAP (Boehringer-Mannheim) per 35-mm plate at 12 hours after initial plating. When chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) was used as a reporter, a constitutive expression plasmid for growth hormone (pXGH5) was cotransfected to control for variations in transfection efficiency. Levels of expression among different cell types were compared by normalizing the expression of test constructs relative to the expression of CAT in the same cell type driven by the SV40 promoter/enhancer (pCAT-Control, Promega).
Transgenic Mice
Transgenic mice were generated by pronuclear injection of the
linearized pCAT-1.2 HFABP construct exclusive of vector sequence
(U.A.B. N.I.C.H.D. center). Positive animals were identified by
the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) screening with the use of
CAT-specific primers and confirmed through Southern blotting. All
animal studies were conducted according to protocols approved by
institutional animal studies committees.
Reporter Assays
CAT activity in cell lysates and tissue homogenates
was analyzed with the use of a diffusion assay with
[14C]-labeled chloramphenicol, with multiple
aqueous back extractions to minimize background. hGH (human growth
hormone) level in tissue culture media was analyzed with the
use of the hGH-TGES 100T sandwich RIA kit (Nichols Institute). A
regression with the use of known hGH standards was computed, and counts
were converted into ng hGH/mL media equivalents. For tissue samples,
activity was normalized to total protein content (Biorad).
Nuclear Extracts and Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays
Nuclear extracts were prepared from
100 mg of tissue
snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen.28 Double-stranded DNA
fragments for electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) were
synthesized as oligonucleotides and annealed. The
sequence of the 42-bp fragment encompassing the CArG-like element (see
infra) from HFABP was (-115)
5'-CCCTAGCCTGGGGCTTCCTATTTCGGGAGCCGGGGGCG -TG GGCCACGTCT-3';
the shorter 20-bp element that encompassed the same core sequence was
5'-CTTCCTATTT CGGGAGCCGG-3'. The 44-bp fragment that encompassed the
adjacent E boxes and TATA boxes had sequence 5'-CCTGCCCGGG CTGCCGCTTT
AAATAGCCCT CGCATCACAT GAGG-3'. The MEF2 site from the muscle creatine
kinase (MCK) promoter contained the core sequence 5'-CGCTCTAAAA
ATAACCCT-3'. Adjacent GATC linkers were present, which permitted
labeling with the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase.
Each EMSA binding reaction contained 4% Ficoll, 5 mmol/L MgCl2, 50 mmol/L KCl, 5 mmol/L DTT, 25 mmol/L HEPES, pH 7.4, 1 µg sonicated Herring sperm DNA, 4 µg nuclear extract, and 25 000 counts of labeled probe. Reactions that contained reticulocyte lysate also contained 0.1 µg of single-stranded nonspecific oligonucleotide to reduce lane background. A 40-fold molar excess of cold competitor was added unless otherwise indicated. After a 20-minute incubation at room temperature, complexes were resolved with a 4% polyacrylamide gel in a buffer containing 45 mmol/L Tris, 45 mmol/L boric acid, and 1 mmol/L EDTA, pH 8.0. Phosphoimaging and quantification were performed on the dried gel.
For supershifts, 0.5 µL of rabbit polyclonal antibody29 or nonspecific rabbit serum was preincubated for 10 minutes with the nuclear extract.
DNAase I Footprint Analysis
Each reaction mixture that contained 25 000 cpm of end-labeled
DNA (-351 to +29, Sph1 to Xba1), 10 µg of
poly-dIdC, 30 µg of nuclear extract, 10 mmol/L Tris, pH 8,
5 mmol/L MgCl2, 1 mmol/L CaCl2, 2
mmol/L DTT, 50 µg/mL BSA, 2 µg/mL salmon sperm DNA, and 100
mmol/L KCl in a final volume of 200 µL was equilibrated at
room temperature for 10 minutes before the addition of 0.001 to 0.03 U
of DNAase I. After digestion at 37°C for 2 minutes, DNAase I activity
was inhibited by the addition of stop solution (645 µL 100% ethanol,
5 µL 1 mg/mL tRNA, and 50 µL saturated ammonium acetate), and the
DNA fragments precipitated. Samples were resuspended in 95% formamide,
20 mmol/L EDTA with dye markers, heated to 80°C, resolved on a
6% denaturing gel, and autoradiographed.
Computation of the Probability Weight Matrix
A computer program was written (J.N.R.) to apply arbitrary
position weight matrices (PWM) to DNA sequences, with numerical PWM
values from Fickett.30 Predicted probability values were
normalized to a linear 0% to 100% scale as described. Because this
PWM is not symmetric with respect to reverse complementation, 2 values
were computed at each residue that consisted of the application of PWM
to the sense strand starting at that residue and the application of the
PWM to the complementary strand terminating at that residue.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
10 kb.
Exon 1 contains the complete 5'-untranslated sequence and codes for the
first 24 amino acids. Exons 2 and 3 code for 59 and 34 amino acids,
respectively; exon 4 codes for the final 16 amino acids and the
3'-untranslated region. The first consensus polyadenylation signal
AATAAA falls 228 nucleotides after the termination codon.
All intron-exon boundaries correspond to the usual GT-AG rules for
eukaryotic splice donors and acceptors, and the intron-exon
structure is conserved among FABP3, the FABP gene, and the
other members of the FABP family whose genomic structures have been
determined. A highly informative dinucleotide (GT) repeat
polymorphism was identified in the third
intron.31
|
During the cloning of the FABP3 gene, a highly similar (80% identity) intronless genomic sequence, suggestive of a processed pseudogene, was identified. These 2 genomic sequences, FABP3 and the putative pseudogene, were the only genomic sequences detected on high-stringency Southern blotting (data not shown) consistent with the identity of the human HFABP and the highly related (>95% identical) MDGI.
Although several transcription start sites from 45 to 63 nucleotides 5' to the ATG encoding the initiator methionine were observed on primer extension studies (data not shown), transcription initiated predominantly at the start site closest to the translation initiation ATG. This site (designated as +1 subsequently) closely corresponded to the transcription start site previously identified for HFABP in the rat.15
Human and Mouse HFABP 5'-Flanking Sequences Are Highly
Conserved
The expression patterns of HFABP protein and mRNA are very similar
between human and mouse.14 15 16 32 Thus, although the
order, context, and even sequences of important regulatory elements may
differ between these 2 orthologs, highly conserved genomic sequence
might signal important transcriptional regulatory motifs. A mouse
genomic library was screened with the murine HFABP coding sequence.
Clones corresponding to the gene 5'- and 3'-ends were identified by
PCR, restriction mapped, and sequenced. The human and mouse 5'-flanking
sequence were compared with the program MACAW to identify regions of
statistically significant evolutionary conservation, which are
identified as the shaded sequences in Figure 1b
.33 34 Within the proximal 1200 bp of the
5'-flanking sequence, the order of the conserved sequences was
maintained although the spacing differed. Some of these regions were
similar to known motifs such as an 11/14 match for the chicken troponin
T CArG box35 occurring 40 bp upstream of the TATA box,
although others did not correspond to established skeletal muscle or
cardiac transcriptional motifs. Canonical GATA or peroxisome
proliferatoractivated receptors (PPARs) direct repeat (DR)
sites were not present.
Transient Transfections Suggest a Compact Promoter Region of HFABP
Confers Specific Expression
Previous data that concerned tissue distribution of HFABP
expression was based on antibodies with cross-reactivity to other
members of the FABP family or mRNA hybridization with cross-species
probes under differing degrees of stringency. High-stringency Northern
blots with species-specific probes in rat and mouse confirmed
8-fold
higher expression in heart, both atrium and ventricle, than in slow
skeletal muscle, with far lower expression in fast skeletal
muscle.15 Low levels of expression were detected in ovary,
testis, adrenal, and kidney; expression was not detected in adipose
tissue, brain, liver, or intestine. Endogenous HFABP mRNA
was readily detected in primary neonatal ventricular
myocytes.
Primary ventricular myocytes were therefore used as a
permissive cell type in transient transfection assays to suggest
essential promoter sequences. Reporter constructs with regions of the
FABP3 5'-flanking sequence coupled to the bacterial CAT
reporter were constructed and transiently transfected. Expression of a
0.4 kb HFABP 5'-sequence/CAT reporter construct was at 120-fold over
basal CAT expression, which corresponded to 74% of the level of a
CAT-SV40 enhancer-promoter construct (Figure 2a
). A decrease in CAT activity was
observed with an addition of 200 bp more of promoter context, which
suggested the presence of a negative regulatory element in this region
(Figure 2a
, P<0.05 versus 0.4 construct). The
addition of another 600 bp of promoter context resulted in a
significant increase in CAT activity to twice that of the 0.4 kb
construct or 125% of CAT-SV40 promoter-enhancer (Figure 2a
, P<0.05 versus other constructs), which suggested the
presence of a positive element in the cardiac ventricular
myocytes within this 600 bp region.
|
In contrast, no significant expression was observed in CaCo-2 cells,
which support the expression of analogous constructs derived
similarly from the intestinal FABP36 (Figure 2b
), or in passaged fibroblasts co-isolated with the primary
ventricular myocytes (data not shown).
Primary ventricular myocytes permitted the comparison of transgene and endogenous HFABP expression. However, their unsuitability for permanent transfections would hinder the mapping of elements underlying metabolic regulation. To determine whether other cell lines might permit the comparison of endogenous HFABP and transgene expression, Northern blots containing mRNA from a variety of permanent cell lines were hybridized with a specific HFABP probe. No signal was observed in any permanent cell line tested, including the myoblast/myotube lines C2C12, Sol8, and LE9, the atrial tumor-derived line AT1 in either proliferative or contracting conditions, and a variety of noncardiac/nonmuscle cell lines (CaCo-2, HepG2, and fibroblast; data not shown) under conditions in which expression in primary ventricular myocytes were readily detected. Although the expression of HFABP in C2C12 cells has recently been reported, protein expression was observed at <1/40th the level observed in primary skeletal myocytes, and this level of expression required especially long (>6 days) periods of differentiation with insulin supplementation.37
During an analogous situation, no established enterocytic cell line
expressed significant levels of intestinal FABP, but it was still
possible to use CaCo-2 cells as a transcriptionally permissive
environment that correlated closely with in vivo transgenic
expression.36 With this in mind, expression of HFABP
5'-flanking region/CAT reporter chimeric reporter constructs was
evaluated in transient transfection studies in Sol8 and C2C12 skeletal
myocyte-derived cells. Four hundred bases of the HFABP 5'-flanking
region demonstrated promoter activity in both Sol8 and C2C12 myoblasts,
with CAT activity more than 40-fold greater than basal (promoterless)
activity (Figure 2c
and 2d
) at 16% (C2C12) to 36%
(Sol8) of the levels of CAT activity observed under the transcriptional
control of the SV40 promoter and enhancer. Constructs based on 600 bp
of the HFABP 5'-flanking sequence showed reduced but comparable levels
of CAT activity relative to the 400 bp construct (Figure 2c
and 2d
, P<0.05 for comparison between 400 bp and 600 bp) in
both Sol8 and C2C12 cells, which suggests the presence of a negative
cis regulatory element for these cell types between -400
and -600 in the HFABP promoter. In C2C12 and Sol8 cells, the addition
of another 600 bp of promoter context resulted in a significant
decrease in CAT activity to less than half that observed with the 0.4
kb construct (Figure 2c
and 2d
; P<0.05 versus 0.4
HFABP construct). The contrast between these skeletal muscle-derived
cell lines and primary ventricular myocytes suggests that
the region between -600 and -1200 contains cis sequences
that differentially activate or inhibit in heart muscle
compared with skeletal muscle.
Expression of HFABP Promoter Constructs Is Not Significantly
Increased With Myotube Formation
Sol8 and C2C12 cells undergo a myoblast to myotube differentiation
process when removed from FBS. The expression of constructs based on
the promoters of a number of sarcomeric proteins, such as the
ß-myosin heavy chain, significantly, reproducibly, and rapidly
increase during this in vitro model of myocyte terminal
differentiation.38 During conditions in which these
changes occurred, no significant change was observed with these 3 HFABP
promoter constructs between myoblasts and myotubes (Figure 2c
and 2d
, light versus dark cross-hatching).
To investigate further this apparent lack of differentiation
dependence, pooled permanent C2C12 and Sol8 transfectants harboring
HFABP 5'-flanking sequences coupled to an hGH reporter were
constructed. This secreted reporter allowed the continuous readout of
activity in the same population of cells during differentiation.
Measurable hGH activity could not be detected in media in the absence
of transfected hGH reporter constructs, and typical activity in the
media from the pooled permanent transfectants was >100-fold above
levels required for accurate detection by radioimmunoassay. Activity in
the media was normalized to that of parallel platings of the same
number and type of cells permanently transfected with a constitutive,
"indifferent" promoter construct based on the metallotheionein
promoter, pXGH5. Characteristic results for the 0.4 kb HFABP promoter
in Sol8 cells are shown in Figure 3
.
During the 96-hour observation period, myotube formation was readily
and consistently observed under differentiation conditions
(Figure 3
, myotube) and not significantly present in cell
populations continued in growth media (Figure 3
, myoblast).
There were no significant differences in the relative levels of
expression of 0.4 HFABP-hGH between these cell populations. Similar
results were observed with constructs based on 0.6 kb and 1.2 kb of the
HFABP promoter in Sol8 and with these 3 constructs in C2C12 cells (data
not shown). These data contrast with the strong induction observed with
differentiation in these same cell types with some well-characterized,
sarcomeric tissue-specific promoters such as the ß-myosin heavy chain
(data not shown).38
|
Expression of the 1.2-kb HFABP Promoter Is Tissue-Specific In
Vivo
The expression in tissue culture may or may not accurately reflect
true in vivo expression for FABPs.36 39 Audits in
transgenic mice were used to confirm the apparent tissue-specificity of
the 1.2 kb HFABP promoter region. Three independent lines with germline
transmission were generated in C57BL6 mice. Quantitative Southern
blotting revealed 5 to 10 copies of the reporter per germline (data not
shown). Relative levels of expression in different tissues in these
lines were similar, and levels of expression among lines were roughly
proportional to copy number (data not shown).
The pattern of transgene expression observed was similar to the tissue
distribution of endogenous HFABP.
Representative data from one line are shown in Figure 4
. Expression in the heart was 20-fold
higher than in any other tissue and >3 orders of magnitude above
background levels of the assay. Separate dissections of the septum,
right and left ventricular free walls, and atria showed
minimal differences in expression of both the transgene and the
endogenous protein (data not shown). The next highest
levels of expression were observed in the lung. Lower levels of
expression were observed in brown fat and skeletal muscle. Expression
in most other tissues samples was at levels that approached the limits
of detection by the assay.
|
Point Mutation in a Conserved CArG-Like Element Reduces Expression
in Permissive Cells
The transgenic data provided compelling confirmation that 1.2 kb
of the HFABP promoter contained most or all of the elements required
for tissue-specific expression. The large number of highly conserved
motifs within this relatively short region suggested that expression
might depend on synergistic interactions. We therefore initiated a
sequential analysis of the conserved elements. The TATA-box
sequence itself is identical between mouse and human and is immediately
adjacent to an E box (CATGTG, consensus CANNTG) that also resembles a
high-affinity Nkx-2.5 site (TCATGTG, consensus TNNATGT). The
next identical region between human and mouse (Figure 1b
, nt
-68 to -107) contained a GC-rich palindromic CACG sequence and a
17-base sequence that is also found in the porcine HFABP-flanking
sequence (5'-CTT CCT ATT TCG GGA GC-3').40 This
latter CArG-like element, an 11/14 match for the chicken troponin T
CArG box, matches the yeast MADS-box transcription factor MCM1
consensus.41 SRF and MEF2, other members of the MADS-box
family that also bind to specific A/T-rich sites, have been extensively
implicated in muscle-specific and heart-specific gene
expression.41 Because the transient transfection
experiments suggested that the proximal promoter region might direct
specific expression in muscle, with more upstream regions responsible
for preferential expression in the heart, we studied this element.
DNAase protection with the use of the 0.4 kb fragment of the HFABP
5'-flanking sequence revealed a difference in the protection conferred
by heart nuclear extracts in the region around the CArG-like element
compared with that observed in the absence of nuclear protein (Figure 5a
). DNAase hypersensitive bases flanked
the region of protection: a pattern that is often associated with
transcription factor binding. Differences between heart and liver
nuclear extracts were less clear (Figure 5a
), but this was not
surprising because the tissue distribution of MADS-box factors is
broader than would be suggested by their role in tissue-specific
expression.41
|
We constructed a one-base mutation in this element,
CCTATTTCGG
CCGATTTCGG, in which
the intrinsic spacing and context was maintained. Transfections of the
single-base change CArG-box mutant into ventricular
myocytes resulted in a consistent and statistically significant
(Figure 5b
, P<0.01) reduction in CAT activity
compared with the unmutated construct. Similar decreases in activity
were observed with the use of this altered promoter with an hGH rather
than a CAT reporter (data not shown) and with transient transfection of
these promoter constructs into C2C12 cells (Figure 5b
). Thus,
the CArG-like element is necessary for full promoter activity in both
ventricular myocytes and skeletal muscle cells. In
contrast, no change in the levels of expression between the native and
mutant constructs was observed in the far lower relative levels of
expression observed with transfections into nonmyogenic 3T3 cells (data
not shown).
MEF2 Overexpression Transactivates the HFABP Minigene
Expression
Serum response factor (SRF), a MADS-family transcription factor,
transactivates a variety of promoters that contain a serum
response element (SRE).42 Because of the similarity of the
CArG-like element to an SRE, on the basis of its similarity to the
troponin element, and the length of its A/T rich core, we determined
whether exogenous SRF could transactivate the 0.4 HFABP
promoter. Expression of exogenous SRF by cotransfections of 1 µg of
an expression plasmid: 6 µg reporter resulted in a 50% to 60%
decrease in the CAT activity from pCAT-0.4HFABP in both C2C12 and 3T3
cells used as models of permissive and nonpermissive cell types (Figure 6b
, CAT activity expressed relative to
basal expression for each cell type). Lesser degrees of downregulation
were observed with transfections of smaller quantities of SRF
expression plasmid (data not shown). Although squelching has often been
observed with overexpression of SRF, its exogenous overexpression is
capable of transactivation of other promoters and
elements.43 44 45 Neither cotransfections of the null
expression plasmid with pCAT-0.4 HFABP nor cotransfections of SRF with
an indifferent positive CAT control resulted in significant
downregulation of corrected activity (data not shown). Cotransfection
of SRF with a weak transactivatable SRE (SRE.LP)46 47
resulted in upregulation in both 3T3 and C2C12 cells (data not
shown).
|
Surprisingly, cotransfections of the MADS-box factor MEF2A, which has a
canonical consensus target
(C/T)TA(A/T)4(T/A)(G/A),41 resulted
in a strong and dose-related increase in CAT activity in 3T3 cells,
with up to a 14-fold increase (Figure 6a
, solid line, left
vertical axis). These experiments used an isolate of 3T3 that has
little endogenous MEF2 binding activity and normally
expresses pCAT-0.4 HFABP at relatively low levels. A smaller relative
increase compared with basal levels of expression of the pCAT-0.4 HFABP
construct was observed in C2C12 cells (Figure 6a
, dashed line,
right vertical axis), which express significant endogenous
levels of MEF2 isoforms. Higher ratios of MEF2A plasmid: reporter
plasmid were also required for increased activity in C2C12 cells, which
possibly reflect higher endogenous levels, although
possible differences in the efficiency of pMT2-MEF2A expression
preclude comparison of true transcription factor dose-response. MEF2A
overexpression increased activity of constructs based on longer HFABP
5'-flanking sequences (Figure 6d
), which demonstrates that this
transactivation was not an artifact of a specific element removed from
its endogenous context. The single-base mutation in the
CArG-like element, which decreased promoter expression in
muscle/myogenic cells, abrogated MEF2A-dependent transactivation in 3T3
cells (Figure 6c
) and C2C12 cells (data not shown). Thus, the
CArG-like element was necessary and sufficient for MEF2A
transactivation.
MEF2A Specifically Binds to the HFABP CArG-Like Element
The MEF2A transactivation could be indirect or direct. We
determined whether MEF2A could bind directly and specifically to the
HFABP CArG-like element.
MEF2 binds avidly and specifically to an A/T rich element from the MCK
upstream promoter. Both 40 and 20 bp double-stranded
oligonucleotides that contained the core HFABP
CArG-like element competed binding of the ventricular
nuclear extracts to the canonical MCK-MEF2 sequence (Figure 7a
, lanes 4 and 5). Competition was less
effective than with an equimolar cold MCK-MEF2 sequence (Figure 7a
, lane 3), which suggested a lower binding affinity for MEF2
to the HFABP site. Similar binding and competition were observed with
nuclear extracts derived from differentiated C2C12 cells, which possess
high MEF2A binding activity.29 This difference in affinity
was explored further in a titration-competition experiment (Figure 7b
). Least-squares modeling of retarded counts fit to a logistic
equation was consistent with a 14-fold difference in
dissociation constants between the MCK and HFABP MEF2 sites.
|
MEF2A produced by in vitro translation with reticulocyte lysate
produced a retarded complex with the HFABP CArG-like site, although no
such complex was observed with unprogrammed reticulocyte lysate (Figure 7c
, lanes 1 and 2, respectively). With the same HFABP CArG-like
element probe, a complex of similar mobility was observed with nuclear
extracts prepared from ventricular muscle (Figure 7d
, lane 2) or C2C12 myotubes (Figure 7e
, lane 2). In
both cases the complex was specifically competed by either excess cold
HFABP CArG site or the MCK-MEF2 site (Figure 7d
and 7e
, lanes 3
to 5). Finally, the HFABP CArG-element complex formed with nuclear
extracts from ventricular muscle, C2C12 myotubes, or
programmed reticulocyte lysate was supershifted by preincubation with a
highly specific MEF2 antibody (Figure 7f
, lane 2, 5, and 15). No
supershift was observed with nonspecific rabbit serum in parallel
reactions (Figure 7f
, lanes 3, 6, and 17) or with unprogrammed
reticulocyte lysate (Figure 7f
, lane 16). Increasing antibody
resulted in near total shift of the complex (data not shown), and
antibody to SRF (SC194x, Santa Cruz) did not shift or alter the complex
(data not shown). The supershift mobility corresponded to that observed
with the same antibody and nuclear extracts bound to the MCK-MEF2 site
(Figure 7f
, compare lanes 7 to 12). Total counts present in
the unshifted and supershifted bands typically exceeded those seen in
control and preimmune reactions, which suggested that the antibody
stabilized the DNA/protein complex (Figure 7f
).29
Quantitative Modeling of the CArG-Like Element as an MEF2
Site
These data suggested that the CArG-like element was a bona fide
MEF2 response element, capable of both specific protein-DNA binding and
transactivation. This element did not correspond to any of the
suggested MEF2 consensus sequences: YTAAAAATAACYY, TWWWAATAR,
CTAWWWWTAG, YTWWAAATAR, or YTAAAWATARCY.48 The PWM has
been suggested as a more precise and quantitative approach to define
transcription factor target sites, and a matrix has been defined for
MEF2. In this approach, a numerical weight is assigned to each base in
each position (first, second, third base, etc) of a putative element in
proportion to this frequency of that base in that position in a
population of documented response elements, generalizing the use of
degenerate codes in consensus elements and allowing quantitative
assessment. The CArG-like element scored 68%, similar to the myoglobin
gene MEF2/ATF35 site,49 but well below the 80% cutoff
suggested for identification of typical MEF2 sites. We applied this
same weight matrix computation to the 1400 bps that surround the HFABP
promoter (a portion is illustrated in Figure 8
). Of the 16 sites that scored at the
same or higher level, only 2 were conserved between human and mouse:
the CArG-like element and the HFABP TATA box. The highest
score of 88% was for the HFABP TATA box. MEF2 is known to
bind to a number of TATA box sites,49 and we have
confirmed that the HFABP TATA box effectively competes for MEF2 binding
on EMSA with both rat ventricular myocyte nuclear extract
and C2C12 nuclear extract (data not shown). However, the mutagenesis
studies described are inconsistent with the HFABP TATA box
mediating MEF2 transactivation.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The in vitro pattern described here differs in one important aspect
from what has been commonly observed with sarcomeric proteins such as
the myosin heavy chains: expression appears to be cell-type specific
but is not substantially upregulated with differentiation of myoblasts
to myotubes. A recent report describes the induction of
endogenous HFABP mRNA in C2C12 cells with differentiation.
However, the extremely low level of expression, at 1/40th of the level
of primary skeletal myocytes, and the modest level of induction,
3-fold, complicate the interpretation of this
finding.37 The time course of this induction, 6 to 8 days
after the change to differentiation medium, is substantially longer
than is typically required (eg, myosin). Finally, the addition of
insulin to the differentiation medium was required, which suggested
that differentiation may have been permissive for transduction of a
metabolic signal rather than directly causal. The high
density of conserved elements in the HFABP promoter suggests that it
will be a useful system in which to study specific transcription factor
interactions, particularly the interaction of tissue-specific and
metabolic signals. The in vivo and in vitro data, taken
together, suggest that the 0.4 kb promoter suffices to specify muscle
expression, although elements farther upstream in the 1.2 kb promoter
are required for the highly enriched expression in the heart. Auditing
of additional constructs in vivo will be required to confirm this
hypothesis.
Some of the motifs and factors responsible for directing the expression
of HFABP are reminiscent of those known from contractile genes. MEF2
has been identified in the promoter regions of a number of genes
expressed at high level in the heart, including muscle creatine kinase,
-myosin heavy chain, myosin light chains, desmin, aldolase A,
cytochrome C oxidase Vla, and the glucose facilitative transporter
GLUT4.59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 Interestingly, although only a few
metabolic genes have been studied, MEF2 sites seem to be
disproportionately represented in this population. The MEF2
site in the HFABP promoter does not correspond to any of the
established MEF2 consensus sequences. However, several lines of
evidence point to a direct role of MEF2 or a closely related molecule:
the binding of in vitro translated MEF2 to the site, the
cross-competition between the HFABP CArG-like site and the MCK-MEF2
site, and the supershifts with a highly specific antibody. Although the
atypical MEF2 (or MEF2-related) binding site is necessary for full
expression of the HFABP construct in the myocytic cell lines tested, it
cannot by itself be sufficient. First, the various isoforms of MEF2 are
widely expressed in a variety of permissive and nonpermissive cell
types by the time of definitive organogenesis, and available functional
assays suggest considerable overlap and redundancy in isoform-specific
pathways. Second, point mutations of the MEF2 site that eliminate MEF2
transactivation do not reduce promoter activity to background levels of
expression. Third, the 0.4 kb region, which encompasses the MEF2 site,
appears not to provide the appropriate gradient of cardiac and skeletal
muscle expression. The lower affinity for direct MEF2 binding and the
conserved presence of an E-box site at 2.5 helical turns suggest that
combinatorial factor interactions involving MEF2 or an MEF2-like
protein with shared epitopes may be necessary for full in vivo effect.
The minimal changes in expression observed with the differentiation of
C2C12 myoblasts to myotubes, despite the substantial upregulation of
MEF2 during this process, favors a balanced interaction requiring
multiple factors. Liu et al65 defined a typical
MEF2 site in the promoter of the GLUT4 gene that was necessary for
full-level expression in C2C12 myotubes. Full expression of constructs
that contain this element was also dependent on flanking sequence; the
differences in differentiation-dependent alterations in level of
expression between the GLUT4 and HFABP constructs may reflect either
differences between their MEF2 sites per se or the flanking
elements.
These other factors may include Sp family members.
Increasing evidence implicates Sp family transcription
factors in the regulation of metabolically important genes
in the heart,68 69 and a concomitant decrease in
Sp1 has been noted during myogenic
differentiation.70 The GC-rich element immediately
adjacent to the CArG-like element satisfies the Sp1-related motif
C(C/G)C(A/T)(C/G)(C/G)(C/G). Both the human and mouse HFABP promoters
contain a potential response element for ERR
, an orphan receptor
implicated in the transcriptional regulation of the important cardiac
metabolic gene medium-chain acyl coenzyme A
dehydrogenase,71 in a highly conserved region at
-700. No canonical GATA or PPAR response elements are
present in the conserved regions in the proximal HFABP
promoter.72 A consistent relationship between MEF2
sites and myogenic E-box sites at a spacing of n+1/2 helical
turns has been noted.30 A conserved E box, immediately
adjacent to the CArG-like element, with exactly this spacing
resembles the high-affinity Nkx-2.5 site 5'-TNNAGTG-3'.73
Although MEF2 and Nkx-2.5 interactions have not yet been
described, the related MADS-box factor SRF interacts with the homeobox
factor Nkx-2.5, and this interaction did not require DNA
binding of both partners.59 Detailed quantitative
studies with combinatorial collections of site mutations and in vivo
footprinting will help elucidate important factor-factor
interactions.
PWM have been suggested as a more quantitative and generally applicable method of predicting factor-binding sites. PWM, which yield a continuous measure of the similarity of a site to those previously established, are more informative for those sites that seem similar to, but fail to meet, traditional consensus measures. Although a modest relaxation of the suggested threshold for MEF2 sites by PWM would include the HFABP site established here, on a genome-wide basis, even a small change would result in a exponential decrease in specificity. Thus, coupling a lowered PWM threshold with other criteria, such as evolutionary conservation or appropriate spacing to correlated sites, may be necessary for realistic use in exploratory genomics.
Effective cardiac contraction is dependent on the coordinate expression of specific contractile, channel, and metabolic genes. The factors and motifs that direct expression of contractile genes have been intensively studied. The metabolic demands of cardiac contraction are extraordinary, and substrate preference and characteristics of energy flux differ substantially between heart and skeletal muscle. This is associated with the expression of certain metabolic genes like the HFABP at substantially higher levels in heart muscle than in other striated muscle. The choice of metabolic substrate by the heart has physiological and clinical significance and is an important determinant of oxygen requirements for constant workload. The HFABP promoter may be a useful tool to direct the expression of exogenous gene products in the heart. In turn, we expect that additional studies can use the compact HFABP promoter to explore in greater detail the interactions of the transcriptional signals that specify tissue identity, metabolic substrate availability, and energy demand: the essential governing elements of cardiac metabolism.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received May 13, 1998; accepted November 11, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-actin promoter activity.
Mol Endocrinol. 1997;11:812822.