Reviews |
From the Heart Institute (M.A.), Sheba Medical Center and Sackler School of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Israel; Department of Genetics (C.E.S., J.G.S.), Harvard Medical School and Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Boston, Mass; and Cardiovascular Division (C.E.S.), Brigham and Womens Hospital, Boston, Mass.
Correspondence to Jonathan G. Seidman, PhD, Department of Genetics, Harvard Medical School, 77 Ave Louis Pasteur, NRB 256, Boston, MA 02115. E-mail seidman{at}genetics.med.harvard.edu
This Review is part of a thematic series on AMP Kinase, which includes the following articles:
AMP-Activated Protein Kinase in the Heart: Role During Health and Disease
AMP-Activated Protein Kinase in Metabolic Control and Insulin Signaling
Bruce Kemp Guest Editor
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
subunit of AMPK lead to enzyme dysregulation and inappropriate activation under resting conditions. Glycogen accumulation ensues, leading to human disease manifesting as cardiac hypertrophy, accessory atrioventricular connections, and degeneration of the physiological conduction system. Whether AMPK is a key participant or bystander in other disease states and whether its selective manipulation may significantly benefit these conditions remain important questions.
Key Words: AMPK glycogen metabolism cardiomyopathy
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This review focuses on the important roles that AMPK plays in normal cardiac physiology and in cardiac disease states. Although cardiomyocytes contain large quantities of AMPK, the contribution of AMPK to normal cardiac function when ATP is abundant and the enzyme is inactive, or during aerobic exercise, remains uncertain. A clearer role has emerged for the function of AMPK in cardiac disease. AMPK is activated during clinically important pathological states such as cardiac hypertrophy and ischemia; whether the enzyme functions in protective processes or serves to exacerbate disease process is disputable and may be disease dependent. Discovery that human mutations of the
subunit, encoded by PRKAG2, cause human cardiomyopathy, characterized by hypertrophy and glycogen accumulation, has stimulated investigations directed toward elaboration of the role of AMPK in cardiac metabolism by studies of genetically engineered mice (Table 1). In addition, considerable information has accrued from analyses of knockout mice lacking
1,
2, or
3 AMPK subunit genes (Table 1). Although initial data regarding AMPK function in these model organisms led to conflicting mechanisms for cardiac disease, these discrepancies have now been largely resolved.
|
Here, we attempt to define the role of AMPK in the heart using insights drawn from clinical phenotype of patients with mutant AMPK and genetically engineered mice carrying AMPK mutations. Using experimental data from both cardiac and skeletal muscle, we offer an integrated picture of cardiac AMPK in health and disease.
| AMPK Structure and Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
AMPK is composed of a catalytic
and regulatory ß and
subunits. Each
subunit contains a phosphorylation site (threonine 172) that plays a critical role in regulating AMPK function. The ß subunit has scaffold-like properties, as well myristoylation, phosphorylation, and glycogen-binding sites1719 (Figure 1). Each
subunit comprises 4 CBS sequences, a motif named after cystathionine ß-synthase, which is found in a wide variety of proteins. Each pair of CBS sequences forms a nucleotide-binding module called the Bateman domain, modules that bind adenosyl compounds. Each
subunit contains 2 nucleotide-binding motifs capable of cooperative binding of 2 molecules of either AMP or ATP, thereby governing the interaction between
and
subunits.2022 AMPK is inhibited at high concentrations of ATP (eg, ATP concentrations found at rest during normal aerobic metabolism), because of ATP binding to the
subunit.23 Binding of AMP to
subunit activates the enzyme by 3 different mechanisms24: allosteric activation; conformational change that enhances Thr172 phosphorylation of the
subunit by upstream AMPK kinases (AMPKK)25,26; and inhibition of Thr172 dephosphorylation by protein phosphatases. (Recent in vitro studies26 using bacterially synthesized AMPK have challenged the interpretation that suggested that AMP enhances Thr172 phosphorylation.) Hurley et al27 have recently suggested that
subunits have another serine phosphorylation site (
1 at residue 485 and
2 at residue 491) that is controlled by cAMP signaling to attenuates AMPK activity.
|
Two isoforms of the
and ß subunits and 3 isoforms of the
subunit are encoded in all mammalian genomes.
1, ß1, and
1 subunits are expressed in nearly every tissue and generally account for most AMPK activity.28 Human
2 and ß2 subunits are robustly expressed in heart and skeletal muscle and are thought to mediate specialized AMPK functions related to intracellular localization. In this regard, it is intriguing that
2 and ß1 subunits contain a putative nuclear localization sequence. Among
subunits,
2 has the highest sensitivity to enzyme activation by AMP.
2 is significantly expressed in several tissues including the heart (Figure 1) but less abundant in skeletal muscle, where the
3 subunit is expressed. Thus cardiac AMPK complexes consist predominantly of
2, ß2, and
2 subunits, whereas skeletal muscle AMPK is characterized by
2ß2
3 complexes (Figure 1).
Elucidating the role of AMPK in maintaining normal cardiac physiology as well as its contribution to cardiac disease has proven to be problematic. During normal cardiac function ATP is abundant, and AMPK is relatively inactive; however, AMPK may be activated during aerobic exercise. Although AMPK is activated during clinically pathological states, such as cardiac hypertrophy and ischemia, its exact role in these disease processes has been disputed and may be disease dependent. Researchers have hypothesized that AMPK both protects the heart and exacerbates disease processes (discussed by Dyck and Lopaschuk7).
Activation by AMP mimetic, the AICA riboside (AICAR) or its intracellular metabolite ZPM (5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide 1-ß-D-ribofuranoside), has been used to study AMPK activity in cultured myocytes, tissue preparations, and isolated perfused hearts. However, issues with AICAR penetration into cardiomyocytes29 and absence of stable cardiac cell lines required extrapolation from skeletal muscle studies, confounding efforts to understand cardiac AMPK function. Because AMPK stimulation increases glucose uptake, AICAR administration to model organisms has produced hypoglycemia, evoking a neurohumoral response. AICAR, previously known as acadesine, was originally designed to increase intracellular adenosine. In addition to its cardioprotective effects, stimulation of adenosine has other consequences on cardiac functions. Collectivel1y, these issues have complicated the interpretation of pharmacological manipulation of AMPK by AICAR.30,31
Genetic studies have provided a complementary approach to biochemical studies of AMPK. Human polymorphisms in genes encoding AMPK subunits have been analyzed in populations with selected metabolic phenotypes. Case-control studies suggested an association between polymorphisms in the
2 subunit gene (PRKAA2) and glucose tolerance and blood cholesterol levels.32,33 Whether these polymorphisms alter AMPK activities, or indicate the consequences of another gene, is unclear. In contrast, Mendelian disorders have been characterized that reflect mutations only in the
2 subunit gene (PRKAG2).34 In humans, dominant PRKAG2 mutations cause cardiac hypertrophy associated with abnormal glycogen accumulation and conduction system disease. The clinical features of these mutations (Table 2) have suggested unexpected cardiac functions for AMPK. The development and study of genetically engineered animal models has further indicated that physiological activity of AMPK is critical for life-long normal heart functions.
|
| AMPK in Cardiac Metabolism |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-adrenoreceptor agonists4,8) stimulate AMPK. Whether these factors mediate AMPK activity in the heart is under active investigation.
|
Two AMPK kinases have been identified in the heart, LKB1 and calmodulin-dependent protein kinase kinase.35,36 The serine/threonine kinase LKB1 appears to function in a myriad of cell processes including AMPK activation. LKB1 responds to anoxic stress by phosphorylating the AMPK
subunit at the Thr172 residue. Notably, this response is independent of AMP concentration.25 LKB1 activity as an AMPK kinase is also dependent on a number of associated proteins.35 During ischemia, LKB1 selectively phosphorylates the
2 but not the
1 subunit, suggesting differential regulation and distinct physiological roles of various catalytic complexes and their upstream kinases.37 Calmodulin-dependent kinase kinase appears to be part of an independent regulatory pathway. Nucleotides released from damaged tissue activate AMPK in endothelial cells through Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent kinase kinase pathway but independently of AMP/ATP ratio.38
Activation of AMPK can influence cardiac metabolism by regulating uptake and oxidative phosphorylation of fatty acids (reviewed by Dyck and Lopaschuk7), the primary source of ATP in normal myocardium. AMPK phosphorylates acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC), which adds a carboxyl moiety to acetyl-CoA to yield the 3-carbon molecule malonyl-CoA. AMPK-mediated phosphorylation of ACC at serine residues (Ser79 in the hepatic isoform and Ser221 in muscle isoform) inactivates ACC. In the liver, malonyl-CoA is required for fatty acid synthesis. In the heart, malonyl-CoA as an inhibitor of carnitine palmitoyl transferase (CPT1), which is located at the outer mitochondrial membrane and is the rate-limiting step for internalizing and rendering fatty acids as substrates for oxidative phosphorylation. Hence activation of AMPK inhibits ACC and triggers a cascade of regulatory events that ultimately activate CPT1 and provide cardiac mitochondria with a preferred substrate for energy production: acyl carnitine.
This pathway is also regulated by malonyl-CoA decarboxylase (MCD), which degrades malonyl-CoA. There is controversy over whether or not MCD is activated during muscle contraction by AMPK.39,40 In vitro transfection studies by Sambandam et al41 suggest that this regulation occurs within mitochondria, rather than in the cytosol. In addition to preventing malonyl-CoA formation, AMPK appears to inhibit triglyceride synthesis in liver and muscle by interacting with glycerol-3-phosphate acyl transferase.42
Further evidence for the role of AMPK in stimulating cardiac fatty acid metabolism comes from analyses of individual cardiomyocytes. Addition of fatty acids to culture medium increases AMPK activity by an unknown mechanism.43 Thus, concomitant with delivery of acyl carnitine to mitochondria, AMPK increases the uptake of free fatty acids to cardiomyocytes. In addition, AMPK stimulation increases protein expression and plasmalemma content of fatty acid transporter (FAT/CD36) and membrane-associated fatty acid binding protein (FABPpm).44 The availability of free fatty acids in the vicinity of cardiomyocytes is further enhanced by increased synthesis and recruitment of lipoprotein lipase to capillary lumen.45
Stimulation of glucose is another established activity of AMPK, although the mechanism and physiological relevance of this activity are not well understood.46 AMPK stimulation of glucose uptake occurs via an insulin-independent mechanism. Early studies demonstrating that activated AMPK increased expression of glucose transporters, GLUT1 and GLUT4, suggested that GLUT4 is translocated from intracellular reservoirs to the sarcolemma to mediate AMPK effect on glucose uptake.4749 Yang and Holman50 suggested that AMPK increases the sarcolemmal GLUT4 transporter number by decreasing endocytosis. The molecular mediators of these events and the specific phosphorylation targets of AMPK may include protein kinase C,51 endothelial nitric oxide synthase,52 and p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase/transforming growth factor ßactivated protein kinase 1binding protein 1 (TAB1) complex.53 This AMPK-dependent pathway does not cross-communicate with the insulinglycogen synthase kinase pathway and in fact may be mutually antagonistic. Insulin inactivates AMPK through Akt,54 and AMPK may inhibit insulin signaling.55 Alternatively, under pharmacological stimuli, AMPK can potentiate insulin signaling downstream protein kinase B,56 thereby helping to overcome insulin resistance.
The physiological importance of AMPK-mediated glucose uptake at rest and aerobic activity is not well defined.57,58 AMPK appears to control a different intracellular pool of transporters from that mobilized by insulin. The effect of insulin predominates at rest or during exercise, whereas the contribution of AMPK to glucose uptake and metabolism becomes central during oxidative stress,50 ischemia,49,59 and pathological hypertrophy.60,61
AMPK stimulates glycolysis directly by activating phosphofructokinases, which provide the primary regulatory step in the glycolytic pathway. AMPK indirectly activates phosphofructokinase (PFK1) through its phosphorylation of phosphofructokinase 2 (PFK2), which converts fructose 6 phosphate to fructose-2,6-diphosphate, an allosteric stimulator of PFK1.62 The capacity of AMPK to activate PFK and increase glycolysis makes it an essential component in mounting the cellular response to energetic stress like anaerobic exercise, anoxia, and low-flow ischemia.
Finally, AMPK plays an important role in regulating glycogen metabolism. AMPK mutations affect glycogen metabolism,63 whereas primary defects in glycogen metabolism (eg, muscle phosphorylase [GP] deficiency, glycogen storage disease type II, or McArdle disease) activate AMPK while decreasing glycogen synthase (GS) activity.64 Carling and Hardie12 suggested that GS and phosphorylase kinase might be phosphorylated by AMPK. AMPK phosphorylates GS at Ser7 and inhibits it in skeletal myoblasts, rendering it glucose-6-phosphate (G-6-P) dependent.65 Paradoxically, repeat AICAR administration resulted in increased glycogen.47 The issue could be settled if AICAR increased the level of G-6-P, thereby overcoming GS inhibition.66 In another study, AICAR inhibited GS and activated GP in white but not red gastrocnemius in vivo.67 These effects could not be reproduced in vitro, which led these authors to conclude that the observed increase in glycogen was attributable to increased glucose uptake but not altered GS or GP. In isolated rat hearts, AMPK-activator AICAR increased glycogen breakdown but did not affect GS or GP activity, leaving the mechanism unknown.68 Hence, the pathways by which AMPK controls glycogen synthesis and breakdown and the precise phosphorylation targets remain to be elucidated. Whether AMPK mediates this action by controlling transcription or by controlling glycogen metabolism directly is also not known.
Although many studies have focused on the role of AMPK as a direct mediator of intermediary metabolism, AMPK also mediates transcription of genes involved in lipid and glucose metabolism.69,70 Recurrent muscle AMPK stimulation reproduces the effect of exercise training by increasing the expression of Glut-4 transporter, hexokinase II, mitochondrial biogenesis, and other mitochondrial enzymes (reviewed by Jorgensen et al71). An important mediator of many of these effects is peroxisome proliferatoractivated receptor-
(PPAR
) coactivator 1
(PGC-1
), which increases expression of transcription factors: nuclear respiratory factors 1 and 2, mitochondrial transcription factor A. and PPAR
. Importantly, each of these has its own downstream targets. For instance, the PPAR
controls the genes involved in lipid metabolism.72
The target genes regulated by AMPK in cardiac muscle are undefined at present. Recent evidence indicates that AMPK-mediated modification of gene expression leads to cardiac protection from anoxia and ischemia. Decrease in protein synthesis through eEF2 phosphorylation affords better tolerance to hypoxia-induced stress.73,74 The late phase of ischemic preconditioning involves increased expression and translocation of Glut-4, which appears to be related to PKC-dependent AMPK activation.51 Presumably
2-associated AMPK mediates this activity because the predilection of the
2 subunit for nuclear localization.75 Therefore, the role of AMPK as transcriptional mediator may be particularly important in the human heart, where
2 is much more abundant than
1 subunit. Future studies will be required to distinguish the roles of AMPK as a direct regulator of cardiac metabolism and as a mediator of cardiac transcription.
Mutations in the Human AMPK Regulatory Subunit Cause Glycogen Storage Cardiomyopathy
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Familial association between WPW pattern and left ventricular hypertrophy was described in 1995 in a large family in which the disease was inherited as an autosomal dominant trait and linked to a locus on chromosome 7q3.79 Many of the affected family members had delta waves on ECG and/or preexcitation exposed by adenosine test or experienced symptomatic conduction system disease: sick sinus syndrome or atrioventricular block. A separate study of another family with the same disease80 determined the electrophysiological characteristics of conduction system abnormalities. Delta waves correlated with distinct accessory pathways, which allowed for bidirectional conduction, inducibility of orthodromic atrioventricular reentry tachycardia. The accessory pathways could be treated by catheter ablation. Most individuals with the new syndrome had multiple accessory pathways, a unique feature rarely observed in sporadic WPW. Sick sinus and atrioventricular block often necessitated pacemaker implantation.
The molecular pathogenesis of the new type of cardiomyopathy remained an enigma until 2001, when 2 groups8183 reported 4 mutations in the PRKAG2 gene, responsible for disease in 5 different families (Table 2). Subsequently, 6 additional families harboring 3 different mutations were reported,63 including a novel Asn488Ile mutation in the family in which this syndrome was originally defined.79 Distinct clinical features are associated with PRKAG2 mutations (summarized in Table 2); however, considerable phenotypic variability exists within and between different mutations. For example, the most common cardiac manifestation is left ventricular hypertrophy, which is found in up to 80% of genetically affected individuals. Hypertrophy may be concentric or asymmetric, may cause outflow obstruction, usually progresses over time,84 and may evolve into left ventricular dysfunction and dilatation81,84 (M.A., C.E.S., unpublished data, 2004). Associated right ventricular hypertrophy may also be found.85 The principal electrophysiological abnormalities in young individuals is ventricular preexcitation, found in approximately two-thirds of genetically affected individuals, is often associated with supraventricular arrhythmias (atrial fibrillation and, less commonly, atrioventricular reentry tachycardia). Conduction-system abnormalities develop in
50% of older mutation carriers, often necessitating pacemaker implantation. Sudden cardiac death is not uncommon. Extra cardiac manifestations are usually less pronounced, except in neonatal disease86 but may include seizures, skeletal myopathy,84,87 and hypertension.83
PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy is often misdiagnosed as the more common disease, HCM.63,84 However, the mechanisms by which sarcomere protein gene mutations cause cardiac hypertrophy and PRKAG2 mutations cause cardiac hypertrophy are likely to be distinct. Initially, several models were proposed to explain how PRKAG2 mutations might cause cardiac hypertrophy. Some suggested that PRKAG2 mutations caused energy deficiency, whereas others suggested that abnormal membrane currents or abnormal gene expression/heart development82 caused cardiomyopathy with conduction abnormalities.
However, subsequent studies indicated that PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy is a unique type of glycogen storage disease primarily involving the heart.63 This idea was supported by:
Confirmation of this model came from histologic analyses of formalin-embedded tissue samples, endomyocardial biopsies, and autopsy samples collected from individuals having either R302Q, Thr400Asn, or Asn488Ile mutation.63 All tissue samples displayed a similar pattern: absence of myofiber disarray and less fibrosis than usually found in HCM but, instead, vacuolated myocytes, which remained unexplained in the original pathological reports but were compatible with a storage-process disorder. Residual inclusion bodies in some of the vacuoles consisted of periodic acidSchiff (PAS)-positive material compatible with nonsoluble polysaccharide (Figure 3). Collectively, these data strongly suggested a novel form of glycogen-storage disease, although the precise structures of the accumulated sugars were unclear. More recently, analyses of accumulated carbohydrates in murine models and in the most severe forms of human disease demonstrated that glycogen accumulates in this cardiomyopathy.13,86,89,101 There is a 30-fold increase in cardiac glycogen in mice expressing AMPK carrying the PRKAG2 N488I missense mutation. Subsequent studies of mutationally altered AMPK activity explained the dominant mode of disease inheritance and the phenotypes of cardiac glycogen accumulation and preexcitation in the conduction system.
|
Mice overexpressing PRKAG2 carrying human disease-causing mutations in their hearts have provided useful models for studying the consequences of these mutations. Transgenic mice overexpressing mutant N488I, R302Q, or R531G PRKAG2 cDNA under the control of
-myosin heavy chain (
MHC) cardiac-specific promoter perfectly recapitulate the human PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy.13,89,91 Because the
MHC promoter becomes activated in the hearts of newborn mice at the end of the first week of life, glycogen accumulation becomes pronounced in heart tissue during the second week of life, peaking at 5 weeks of age.13,89 Pronounced cardiac hypertrophy is observed by 2 weeks, peaks at 8 weeks age, and progresses to dilatation and contractile dysfunction by 20 weeks. N488I Transgenic mice display normal ECGs at birth, but, by 2 to 4 weeks, their ECGs exhibit delta waves. Delta waves on the ECG generally correspond to electrophysiological evidence of accessory pathways, which may be exposed by adenosine (blocking the atrioventricular node to expose conduction through accessory connection, if present) and suppressed by procainamide (a sodium channel blocker that slows conduction through the myocardium). PRKAG2 mutant mice experienced sinus bradycardia, atrial tachycardia,89 and atrioventricular tachycardia.91
Classically, preexcitation is considered to result from electrical transmission through well-defined bypass tracts ("bundles of Kent") comprised of bundles of myocardium often in the junctions that form a physical connection between atria and ventricle, by passing the fibrous insulating layer, termed the annulus fibrosis. These discrete tracks can be observed on physical or histologic examination of hearts from WPW patients.90,92 However, preexcitation in transgenic mice expressing mutant AMPK appears to result from a different type of bypass track. In transgenic mice expressing mutant AMPK, and presumably in PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy, disruption of the annulus fibrosis by swollen, glycogen-filled cardiomyocytes produces abnormal tracks by which electrical impulses in the atria can pass directly to the ventricle, bypassing the atrioventricular node (Figure 4). This anatomy is consistent with multiple accessory pathways found in humans and mice with this disease. These disruptions of the annulus fibrosis disappear if glycogen levels are reduced in the cardiac myocytes (C. Wolf, C. Berul, M.A., J.G.S., and C.E.S., unpublished results, 2006).
|
| Effect of PRKAG2 Mutations on AMPK Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 subunit containing complexes account for the minority of AMPK activity in the heart and elsewhere,28,93 one would imagine that haploinsufficiency (ie, mutations that cause inactivation of one allele) would not cause autosomal dominant disease. Further, because AMPK is largely inactive at rest, a gain of abnormal function was likely to account for disease pathogenesis. One approach to study the effect of PRKAG2 mutations on protein function was to introduce mutations, Thr400Asn and Asn488Ile, into the ancient yeast homolog snf4.63 Saccharomyces cerevisiae responds to lack of glucose by inducing expression of genes capable of metabolizing alternative sources of sugar through the action of the Snf1/4 complex. An interaction between Snf4 and Snf1 (the homolog of
and
subunit, respectively) is required for yeast survival on media containing galactose, raffinose, or glycerol but is not required for growth in glucose-containing media.94 Snf4 harboring human mutations increased interaction with snf1 when yeast are grown in glucose-containing media, suggesting inappropriate basal activation of the enzyme complex.
Two groups studied the activity of 2 variantsR70Q
1 and R225Q
3 (which are homologous to human
2 R302Q)in pulmonary fibroblasts and COS cells transfected with
1ß1
1 or
2ß2
3.95,96 Their results were consistent with the model that the mutations increased basal AMPK activity but impaired sensitivity to AMP. By contrast, 2 other groups assessed AMPK activity in CCL13 cells transfected with a larger series of mutant PRKAG2 variants.22,108 PRKAG2 alleles containing R302Q, H383R, T400N, and R531G mutations, which are within CBS sequences, decreased AMPK activity, whereas Ins351Leu, which does not reside within a CBS, had no effect on AMP sensitivity and enzyme activity. The authors concluded that
2 mutations do not cause constitutive AMPK activation and proposed that alternative mechanisms explain the cardiac pathogenesis of these mutations. More recently, Burwinkel et al86 analyzed the effects of R531Q mutation, which causes a fatal neonatal glycogenosis, on AMPK function. Biochemical characterization of mutationally altered AMPK demonstrated a striking impairment of AMP and ATP binding to the
subunit, exceeding the effect of other PRKAG2 mutations. Even the R531G mutation, involving the same residue, has less effect on AMPK function. Functional analyses of R531Q and R531G AMPK, in HEK-293 cells, showed that both mutations increase the basal AMPK activity, concomitant with increased
subunit and ACC phosphorylation, but also abolish the responsiveness of AMPK to AMP.86 Kilimann and colleagues86 suggested that the apparent discrepant effects of human mutations on AMPK activity reflected the use of different cell lines, which contained variable amounts of the main upstream kinase LKB1 in CCL13 cells.35 The current consensus appears to be that in the presence of adequate upstream kinase (LKB1), human mutations increase the basal activity of AMPK and reduce the sensitivity of the protein to AMP.
The consequences of human PRKAG2 mutations on AMPK activity have also been assessed in the myocardium using tissue obtained from transgenic mice expressing mutationally altered PRKAG2. Studies in whole animals are complicated by 2 factors. First, multiple isoforms of AMPK subunits are expressed in cardiac tissue. Overexpression of wild-type or mutant PRKAG2 might lead to altered levels of different AMPK isoforms. Second, glycogen accumulation, which is a signature feature of PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy might be expected to alter AMPK activity. That is, AMPK was reported to be negatively regulated by glycogen.97,98 Although increased expression of
2 protein might have altered the amount of either
1 or
2 in PRKAG2N488I transgenic hearts compared with levels observed in wild-type hearts, no changes in the amounts of these subunits were observed.89 These studies demonstrated that the amount of
2 subunit is not limiting in the myocardium. Then AMPK activity in transgenic hearts was measured in complexes immunoprecipitated by
1 and
2 antibodies in 5-week-old mice with a fully developed phenotype. No differences in AMPK activities were observed between wild-type and transgenic hearts. Because glycogen could inhibits AMPK, we repeated the activity measurements in young (1-week-old) mice, which have little accumulated glycogen (because the transgene is not activated until shortly after birth). In young mutant PRKAG2N488I mice, significant increases in AMPK activity are found, and this increased activity is associated primarily with the
2 subunit. Recent studies13,91 using PRKAG2R302Q and PRKAG2R531G transgenic mouse demonstrated consistent findings. AMPK activity was reduced in enzyme complexes from older transgenic mice but not in 1-week-old mice.
Because wild-type AMPK was activated by AMP, the ability of AMP to activate mutationally altered AMPK was assessed under different conditions. Tian and colleagues59,60,99 used instantaneous freeze-clamped Langendorff-perfused hearts to achieve complete control of the metabolic environment and avoid any anoxia/ischemia associated with in vivo heart extraction. Under these conditions, PRKAG2N488I hearts had increased AMPK activity across a range of AMP concentrations.99 However, AMPK with the PRKAG2 N488I mutations demonstrated reduced activation in response to AMP. These measurements were consistent with earlier studies in cell culture showing decreased nucleotide binding to Bateman domains in mutationally altered
2 subunits.22
These biochemical studies suggest a mechanism by which PRKAG2 missense mutations determine AMPK activity. Under normal physiological conditions, the heart has abundant ATP and nearly absent AMP. Under these conditions, high ATP levels inhibit AMPK. AMPK carrying PRKAG2 mutations has decreased affinity for ATP, causing inappropriate baseline activation of the enzyme. During times of extreme oxidative stress, such as ischemia, when ATP goes down, AMP levels increase and upregulate the enzyme activity. Mutationally altered subunits lack the capacity to sense and respond to this metabolic challenge. PRKAG2 missense mutations thus have a binary effect on enzyme function. Their predominant pathophysiological effect manifests at rest as reducing the affinity for ATP and increasing baseline AMPK activity.
Two other lines of evidence confirm that increased baseline AMPK activity is responsible for PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy. First, PRKAG2 mutations leading to reduced AMPK activity are predicted to produce different phenotypes from mutations that lead to increased AMPK activity100 (Table 1). Several models of genetically engineered mice with altered cardiac AMPK activity have been produced. These models help fill the gap left by absence of suitable pharmacological agents for long-term activation or inhibition of AMPK in vivo. Abrogation of
2 subunit activity leads to decreased AMPK activity, contraction-induced glucose uptake, and skeletal muscle glycogen.101 Finally,
2 dominant-negative transgenic animals had unchanged or decreased cardiac weight and glycogen content. These data strongly suggest that loss of AMPK function does not lead to glycogen-storage cardiomyopathy but, rather, to decreased glycogen levels. Second, a model that PRKAG2 mutations cause disease by increasing baseline activity of AMPK would imply that downregulation of AMPK activity in transgenic mice overexpressing mutant PRKAG2 should prevent cardiomyopathy. Xing et al59 created transgenic mice, designated Tg
2DN, that express a dominant-negative form of the
2 subunit under control of the
MHC promoter in the heart. Tg
2DN mice have reduced cardiac AMPK activity. Compound heterozygous Tg
2DNxPRKAG2N488I mice have reduced AMPK activity and minimal cardiomyopathy, demonstrating that the PRKAG2 missense mutation mediates its effects by activating AMPK. Further analyses of these compound heterozygous mice demonstrated that
2 subunitcontaining AMPK, rather than
1 subunitassociated AMPK, is responsible the cardiac phenotype.103
| The Mechanism of Glycogen Storage |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-AMPKdeficient and
2 dominant-negative transgenic mice have reduced glycogen synthesis capacity and less glycogen. Mice lacking
3 have impaired skeletal muscle glycogen resynthesis after exercise, suggesting a role in regulating glycogen synthesis.96
2 mutations cause severe cardiac glycogen storage (30x) in association with increased AMPK activity and glucose uptake. Interestingly, wild-type
2 transgenic mice, in which wild-type
1 subunits are replaced with
2 subunits, display moderate (5x) glycogen accumulation without measurable change in AMPK activity. Likewise, mice overexpressing either wild-type
3 or R225Q have 2-fold increased muscle glycogen, which is unrelated to AMPK, GS, or GP activity.102
Several groups have now addressed the question of whether the glycogen that accumulates during PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy is available for energy production. Recent studies99,103 have shown that PRKAG2 transgenic mice, either mutant or wild type, can use their accumulated cardiac glycogen during exercise or anoxia as an energy source. Similarly, increased muscle glycogen in R70Q
1 transgenic mice served to improve exercise tolerance.104 These findings suggest that therapeutic approaches to decrease glycogen accumulation in these patients may well "cure" the disease. They also indicate that excess glycogen arises from altered regulation, which does not match synthesis with consumption rather than a defect leading to irreversible deposition of glycogen in cytoplasm (Figure 5). At rest, mutant hearts have increased AMPK activity, increased resting glucose uptake, normal levels of high-energy phosphates, and no substantial increase in tissue lactate, indicating no major excess of glycolysis over the oxidative phosphorylation.101,104 We assume that because heart normally "prefers" fatty acids as fuel105 but has no physiological capacity/enzymatic machinery to store fat; fatty acids undergo oxidation, whereas excess glucose may be directed to storage in the form of glycogen (Figure 5). A possible mechanism of fuel selection may involve inhibition of pyruvate dehydrogenase by free fatty acids, although the role of AMPK in regulating this critical enzyme needs further clarification.106,107
|
Recent spectrophotometric studies of accumulated glycogen in PRKAG2R531G transgenic hearts showed increased absorbance consistent with less branching of carbohydrate chains than found in normal cardiac glycogen.13 Amylopectin (polyglucosan), a nonsoluble glucose polymer, accumulates in glycogen storage disease (GSD) type IV caused by brancher enzyme deficiency.109 In human PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy, similar deposits of nonsoluble cytoplasmic glycogen are found in formalin-preserved cardiac tissue samples.63 The relationship between PRKAG2 mutations and altered glycogen branching remains uncertain.
Integrating these data suggests a complex interaction between metabolic status, level of AMPK subunits, enzyme activity, and glycogen level. All of the myocardial and electrophysiological features of PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy can be explained by inappropriate glycogen accumulation.110,111 Although PRKAG2 mutations create activated AMPK, which leads to glycogen accumulation, the target proteins phosphorylated by the activated AMPK and the precise mechanism(s) that lead to glycogen accumulation are not yet identified. Despite that, we suggest that PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy has many features similar to other classic glycogen storage diseases and should be classified as such (Figure 6). We propose a negative feedback loop in which AMPK is involved in setting the level of cellular glycogen stores (Figure 5). Alterations in AMPK function, for example,
2 mutations or replacing
1 with
2, interfere with metabolic regulation and cause glycogen levels to rise until a new steady state is achieved. In principle, these feedback loops would be appropriately regulated if AMPK were inhibited by glycogen. Although glycogen does bind AMPK via the ß subunit, glycogen binding does not appear to inhibit AMPK.18,19 Perhaps physical association of glycogen with AMPK exposes the enzyme to inhibitory modulation by phosphatases or other mediators. Similarly, the mechanism by which replacing
1 with its
2 homolog upregulates glycogen is unclear but may involve subtle AMPK activation not detectable by conventional assays or different subcellular localization of
2-containing complexes.
|
| The Role of AMPK in Physiological and Other Forms of Cardiac Myocyte Hypertrophy |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because of the wide range of AMPK targets, defining its role in the hypertrophic process has proven difficult. For example, AMPK can be either pro- or antiapoptotic, depending on experimental conditions. The ability of AMPK to upregulate p53116 and mediate Bax translocation to mitochondria117 suggests an antiproliferative function. By contrast, AMPK activity also protects cardiomyocytes from palmitate load or anoxic damage associated with antiapoptotic activity.49,118 Transgenic mice associated with constitutive AMPK activity89 had a net increase in heart muscle mass (after correcting for glycogen and water) and increased expression of hypertrophy associated genes. These are most probably secondary phenomena resulting from the evolving pathological process and not directly from changes in AMPK activity. Because various models associated with decreased AMPK activity did not show any hypertrophy, AMPK may be more of a bystander than a key player in the hypertrophic process. In conclusion, the role of AMPK in cardiac hypertrophy remains unknown.
AMPK may play other roles in altering cardiac myocyte morphology and proliferation. The main AMPK activator, LKB1, is in fact a tumor suppressor gene.35 AMPK activates the tuberous sclerosis tumor suppressor protein complex TSC1-TSC2 to inhibit mTOR signaling and cell growth and proliferation (recently reviewed Motoshima et al8). Interestingly, inactivating mutations in TSC1-TSC2 causes tuberous sclerosis, a syndrome associated with benign tumors including multiple hamartomas and cardiac rhabdomyomas.119 Whether these regulatory functions are related to cardiac disorders should be answered in the near future. One recent exciting study addressed the potential of AMPK stimulation to inhibit coronary atherosclerosis. AMPK activation suppressed vascular smooth muscle proliferation through a p53-dependent mechanism.116 This action is expected to work in synergism with lipid lowering effect120 and improved endothelial function121 to attenuate the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in the western hemisphere.
| AMPK and Cardiac Electrophysiology |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 subunit. The action potential duration was significantly prolonged in
1T172D-transfected myocytes, causing early afterdepolarization. The mutant slowed the open-state inactivation of sodium current similar to the pathophysiology observed in long QT syndrome caused by SCN5a mutations. The relationship of this model to human disease remains unclear, because neither QT prolongation nor torsades de pointes has been reported in PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy. The effect of AMPK mutations on cardiac ion channels requires further study. Hallows et al128 hypothesized that inhibiting transmembrane conductance, by preventing waste of high energy phosphates, might fall within the general role of AMPK. If this rule applies to the heart, one could expect inhibition of ion currents to contribute to bradyarrhythmia and conduction system disease in PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy.
Although PRKAG2 mutations may affect ion channels, studies of murine models strongly suggest that the primary mechanism leading to conduction disease is an abnormal anatomical substrate for electrical coupling between atria and ventricles. Either electrical connections, which normally exist during embryonic life, do not involute or they develop postnatally by muscle tissue penetrating through annulus fibrosis.90 Transgenic mice develop glycogen storage, multiple atrioventricular communications, and preexcitation several weeks after birth (Figure 4).89,129,91 Other glycogen storage disorders, such as Danon disease, also cause preexcitation, probably by a similar mechanism.111 Most likely, there are 2 mechanisms leading to cardiac preexcitation: some forms are caused by glycogen accumulation, whereas others are caused by the formation of accessory bypass tracts formed from abnormal cell proliferation or growth.90,92 This may explain relatively low prevalence of typical WPW arrhythmia (atrioventricular reentrant tachycardia) in PRKAG2 cardiomyopathy despite multiple accessory pathways in the affected individuals (Table 2).
| Conclusions |
|---|